[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-04-02 Thread Andy Whitcroft
We will remove that status file when it reports the bug on the next boot. As there now a hang log that will trigger a different type of bug. We have a number already. They are looking like there is a chvt hang, and there may be a tie in to jumping to the gdm login screen. I am suspicious the x-

Re: [Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-30 Thread Matt Zimmerman
On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 10:23:26AM -, Andy Whitcroft wrote: > I believe the apport changes are sufficient to detect and report this > late-resume issue, closing out the pm-utils task. Shouldn't pm-utils still clean up its lockfile on shutdown? -- - mdz -- resume hangs late in the process

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-30 Thread Andy Whitcroft
I believe the apport changes are sufficient to detect and report this late-resume issue, closing out the pm-utils task. ** Changed in: pm-utils (Ubuntu) Status: In Progress => Invalid -- resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot https://bugs.la

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-30 Thread Launchpad Bug Tracker
This bug was fixed in the package apport - 0.147 --- apport (0.147) jaunty; urgency=low * bin/apportcheckresume: report the pm-suspend.log/pm-hibernate.log from /var/lib. * bin/apportcheckresume: only attempt to attach the stress log if its is present. * bin/apportcheckr

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread Andy Whitcroft
We get a fair amount of additional data in the pm-suspend.log and my latest branch both fixes detection of this kind of failure and adds reporting of this additional logfile -- resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/3

Re: [Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread Matt Zimmerman
On Fri, Mar 27, 2009 at 03:38:49PM -, vlowther wrote: > Matt, if you can reliably reproduce the issue can you attach your > /var/log/pm-suspend.log file to this bug? > > Also after rebooting, can you try running > > PM_DEBUG=true pm-suspend > > as root and attach the /var/log/pm-suspend.log

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread vlowther
If you want to pinpoint exactly where in the resume process it is hanging, and you know it is after the kernel haded control back to pm- utils, you can run pm-suspend with PM_DEBUG=true in the environment -- this will cause pm-suspend and all the hooks to be traced. This is probably one of the hoo

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread vlowther
Matt, if you can reliably reproduce the issue can you attach your /var/log/pm-suspend.log file to this bug? Also after rebooting, can you try running PM_DEBUG=true pm-suspend as root and attach the /var/log/pm-suspend.log that creates to this report? -- resume hangs late in the process appear

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread Andy Whitcroft
Ok. In the process of testing this I think I have hit the actual cause of the issue. If a resume fails late on say resuming bluetooth then the resume may have gotten far enough that the user in front of the screen percieves the machine to be fully functional. They may well see the screen lock an

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread Andy Whitcroft
** Description changed: + If a resume hangs late enough in the resume cycle then the resume may + appear to the user in front of the machine to have completed + successfully. Their screen saver may appear, they can login and use the + machine quite normally. However the suspend really is not com

[Bug 335323] Re: resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot

2009-03-27 Thread Andy Whitcroft
** Summary changed: - (false positive?) [LENOVO 6465CTO] suspend/resume failure + resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot -- resume hangs late in the process appear working and yet report failure on next reboot https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/33532