[Bug 385305] Re: rebuilt initrd with lvm fails to find live fs

2009-09-06 Thread Tormod Volden
Yes, I guess the ugly hack feature does more harm than good. Anyway, see alternative patches in bug #388407. ** Changed in: casper (Ubuntu) Status: New = Confirmed ** Summary changed: - rebuilt initrd with lvm fails to find live fs + [PATCH] fails to boot if RAID (dm-) devices are

[Bug 385305] Re: rebuilt initrd with lvm fails to find live fs

2009-06-17 Thread Tormod Volden
I don't think it is necessary to rebuild the initrd to experience this bug. The shipped initrd has built-in support for dmraid for example, which creates dm-* devices. So you can't boot a Desktop CD if a RAID is around. See bug #388407. -- rebuilt initrd with lvm fails to find live fs

[Bug 385305] Re: rebuilt initrd with lvm fails to find live fs

2009-06-17 Thread Steve Dodd
No dmraid machines around here, but yes, any virtual block devices look as if they would cause problems, ditto any odd (non-PCI, non- USB/IDE) hardware (perhaps on non x86 platforms.) Do you know of / can you think of any situation where the ugly hack would do anything useful? If not, I'd be

[Bug 385305] Re: rebuilt initrd with lvm fails to find live fs

2009-06-09 Thread Steve Dodd
Slight correction to the earlier post: the problematic code in question only seems to be called for non-USB/SCSI/IDE devices (anything whose udev path doesn't match usb|pci-[^-]*-(ide|scsi|usb)) - I've no idea what devices these might be - onboard flash memory (MTDs) in embedded systems?? Anyway,