[Bug 54925] Re: ping provides vague message `Packet filtered'

2011-04-30 Thread Ian Jackson
Josh writes ([Bug 54925] Re: ping provides vague message `Packet filtered'): Ping only knows that the packet was filtered, it doesn't know why and it is not Ping's job to figure out why the packet was filtered. You are entirely wrong. ping has the complete ICMP unreachable packet

[Bug 54925] Re: ping provides vague message `Packet filtered'

2011-04-28 Thread Josh
This seems like working as expected to me. It is correctly informing you that the ICMP packet was filtered by some router in between your computer and the destination. Ping only knows that the packet was filtered, it doesn't know why and it is not Ping's job to figure out why the packet was

[Bug 54925] Re: ping provides vague message `Packet filtered'

2007-11-16 Thread Paul Dufresne
Thank you for this remark. Changing state from new to Confirmed, as there is enough info to let developer decide what to do next. ** Changed in: iputils (Ubuntu) Status: New = Confirmed -- ping provides vague message `Packet filtered' https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/54925 You received