[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-16 Thread Martin Pitt
I'm not that fussed on the implementation details (move script to jockey or make dependency stronger). I was just wondering what the "user experience" here should be: should it be possible to remove nvidia- common and install the upstream driver? I think it should. I'm also happy to just bump jock

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-16 Thread Brandon Snider
"That would mean that you wouldn't have a chance, ever, to try the upstream installer." There is a command-line option that can be used to override the script and proceed with the nvidia-installer. But as Alberto says above, if someone has gotten to that point, they obviously know exactly what the

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-16 Thread Alberto Milone
I guess the idea was to prevent users from installing the nvidia driver from the Nvidia installer unless they know exactly why they are using the installer vs our packages (or the ones from the x-updates PPA) and therefore should know how to 1) override our script and 2) fix their system is somethi

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-16 Thread Martin Pitt
Another point is, if people uninstall nvidia-common, they won't be able to install the packaged nvidia driver through jockey, as jockey needs nvidia-common to do the detection for nvidia. ** Changed in: jockey (Ubuntu) Status: In Progress => Triaged -- You received this bug notification b

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-15 Thread Martin Pitt
Brandon Snider [2011-02-15 20:57 -]: > I'd actually like to see the script attached to a package that cannot be > removed. That would mean that you wouldn't have a chance, ever, to try the upstream installer. You can remove jockey just as well. But anyway, I don't mind much moving it there, i

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-15 Thread Brandon Snider
Martin, I guess what it boils down to is that I'm not as convinced as you are that nvidia-common is finding its way onto everybody's systems. I have been on IRC and observing forum posts going back to the Lucid cycle, when the script was added, and there have been people every day talking about how

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-02-15 Thread Martin Pitt
Actually I don't understand the request here. jockey-common already recommends nvidia-common, which means that nvidia-common is installed by default. As far as I understand the bug, the script should be installed by default, which is already the case. So why would it be better in jockey-common? **

[Bug 704597] Re: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common

2011-01-18 Thread Brandon Snider
-- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/704597 Title: Please move pre-install script to jockey-common -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailm