[Bug 775369] Re: Update manager removes xscreensaver and replaces with gnome-screensaver

2012-04-13 Thread Brian
I guess I should respond eventually! Upgrade does actually remove xscreensaver (the package is gone, the binary is gone, it's gone.), and replaces with it gnome-screensaver. The xscreensaver preferences stored in ~/.xscreensaver are still there, and when gnome-screensaver is (again) removed and x

[Bug 775369] Re: Update manager removes xscreensaver and replaces with gnome-screensaver

2011-06-02 Thread era
Thanks for the link, I was vaguely familiar with the criticisms against gnome-screensaver but it's good to have a reference here. It's probably moot to argue (in this bug) about whether or not ubuntu- desktop should or should not depend on gnome-screensaver, but the fact that you successfully repl

[Bug 775369] Re: Update manager removes xscreensaver and replaces with gnome-screensaver

2011-06-02 Thread Brian
gnome-screensaver is broken and will not be fixed: Bug 22007 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gnome-screensaver/+bug/22007 >From 2005! So the bug here should be against ubuntu-desktop since it depends on a broken package? Unity scared me away when I did the upgrade, and I didn't even b

[Bug 775369] Re: Update manager removes xscreensaver and replaces with gnome-screensaver

2011-05-30 Thread era
This is hardly a bug in update-manager. The output of "aptitude why gnome-screensaver" on my system indicates that ubuntu-desktop depends on gnome-screensaver. You may be able to work around this by installing a dummy equivs package, or perhaps by setting the status of xscreensaver to "hold". I