Re: [Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-11-15 Thread Loye Young
At IYCC, we've seen this problem over and over again, both on IYCC computers and on Ubuntu computers of our customers . We've concluded that avahi is a broken implementation of a bad idea, and the only thing that seems to work reliably is to get it off the machine. Here's the best solution: # apt

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-11-15 Thread Alecz20
avahi-autoipd gives me an IP address which overrides the settings in Network manager. This mean that after each reboot I have no valid network connection. I have to restart the network or re-configure Network manager each time. syslog fragment: [code] Nov 15 17:23:25 vlad-studio avahi-autoipd(ath0

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-08-25 Thread Cyberax
I have a box with two network interfaces: DHCP to WAN and a statically configured local interface. Avahi-autpid constantly resets default route to local network so Internet traffic doesn't go anywhere. Removing avahi fixes this problem for me. -- avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route h

Re: [Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-06-24 Thread Loye Young
>he avahi default route has a very high metric set, this route will only >ever be used by the kernel when there are no other routes available. That's not the behavior we're seeing on Hardy fresh installs. According to RFC 1122, multiple default routes *must* be supported, but in practice that's ho

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-06-24 Thread Steve Langasek
Hi Loye, Actually, where multiple routes are concerned, Trent is correct; because the avahi default route has a very high metric set, this route will only ever be used by the kernel when there are no other routes available. So if you have another device with a real Internet route, that route shou

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-06-24 Thread Loye Young
Steve is right. Setting up a default route on a link-local interface is inherently flawed. The default route is the the "gateway of last resort", i.e., the router address used when no other known route exists for a given IP packet's destination address. However, the basic architectural assumption

Re: [Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-05-29 Thread Steve Langasek
On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 11:45:19PM -, Trent Lloyd wrote: > Anything that is broken by this is inherently broken, not the Avahi > setup - and -they- should be fixed. Er, no, that's nonsense. Applications that generate network traffic have to wait for network timeouts as a result of this avahi

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-05-25 Thread Trent Lloyd
Hi Steve, Anything that is broken by this is inherently broken, not the Avahi setup - and -they- should be fixed. The link local default is installed at the lowest preference, and should not be used if a better one exists. The original bug report was about openswan, what specific problems have y

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2008-05-23 Thread Steve Langasek
I'm confirming this as a bug. I have never seen a situation where a local-link default route has been useful to me, but I have frequently been bitten by the network timeouts that result from this wrong route. I believe that /etc/avahi/avahi-autoipd.action should be fixed to not set a default route

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2007-04-01 Thread Trent Lloyd
That route tells it to just send packets for any IP directly out the interface, this is usefull because in a LAN using zeroconf LL IPs (as avahi-autoipd), only hosts without another non-LL ip should have an LL ip. So without a default (last resort) route out the interface, if you only had an LL ip

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2007-04-01 Thread kaouete
When i start openswan, i get this error message : ipsec_setup: multiple default routes, %defaultroute cannot cope!!! It is because openswan is looking for the interface that manage the defaultroute, since there is several default route, it fails to start. And i can't just specify to it an interfa

[Bug 99489] Re: avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route

2007-03-31 Thread Trent Lloyd
It is not 'useless' it is installed as a last resort thus should not cause any problems It what way does it confuse openswan? -- avahi-autoipd gives me an useless default route https://launchpad.net/bugs/99489 -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/ma