Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-15 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Martin Owens wrote on 13/09/08 04:18: ... One of the concerns I have is with configurations, specifically those in /etc and those in ~/.* . The files in /etc are known to the apt system and it's been built to warn the user if config files are to

Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-13 Thread Andrew Sayers
I like the idea of a FUSE interface to GConf, and I could see extending the idea to some sort of configFS - I seem to remember the ReiserFS guys talking about a similar idea years ago, before recent events overtook them. I think an interface that involves opening

Configuration Validation

2008-09-12 Thread Martin Owens
Dear Ubuntu and APT Developers, I would like to introduce an idea and see if any of you would like to review it and see how helpful it would be to solving a problem. These ideas may have already have been expressed so I'd like to see if they are under development elsewhere. In Debian based

Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-12 Thread Andrew Sayers
Could you spell out some specific issues that this would solve? For example, are you looking to avoid two packages overwriting each other's files in ~/? If so, can you give an example of that happening? - Andrew -- Ubuntu-devel-discuss mailing list

Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-12 Thread Martin Owens
2008/9/12 Andrew Sayers [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Could you spell out some specific issues that this would solve? For example, are you looking to avoid two packages overwriting each other's files in ~/? If so, can you give an example of that happening? Examples: 1) I manually edit a config file

Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-12 Thread Andrew Sayers
I think we've all had that idea at one time or another, but sadly it's based on a misunderstanding of how the community works. Steve Jobs stood atop the mountain and commanded that Mac developers jump to plists, and everyone jumped because that's how Apple development works. If Mark Shuttleworth

Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-12 Thread Martin Owens
I think we've all had that idea at one time or another, but sadly it's based on a misunderstanding of how the community works. Oh no, I understand that people will be people. I don't expect them to agree. But building systems to validate system integrity doesn't require projects approval

Re: Configuration Validation

2008-09-12 Thread Mackenzie Morgan
On Fri, 2008-09-12 at 23:18 -0400, Martin Owens wrote: One of the concerns I have is with configurations, specifically those in /etc and those in ~/.* . The files in /etc are known to the apt system and it's been built to warn the user if config files are to be overwritten. The config files