Re: [uknof] Investigatory Powers Act

2017-01-13 Thread William Waites
> I'd put good money on James being correct, if you receive a notice, you will > know whats needed or will be told - but you won't be able to tell anyone You can, of course, tell some people. Your lawyer, for example, who may or may not wonder about the compatibility of the notice you may or ma

Re: [uknof] Investigatory Powers Act

2016-12-01 Thread William Waites
> • In the UK, government policy is to fund 100% of the reasonable costs > incurred by CSPs in complying with communications data retention notices. > This means that CSPs are not financially disadvantaged by compliance and are > not incentivised to pursue lowest cost solutions. This arra

Re: [uknof] Investigatory Powers Act

2016-12-01 Thread William Waites
Aled, I am not aware of such a guide, but because I have to do with numerous (very) small providers, I have been fielding questions about just this. We are looking at putting together such a guide with help from people specialising in internet law at the law school. We would welcome help from ot

Re: [uknof] IP Bill & Transit Providers

2016-11-17 Thread William Waites
> The question is, do the new powers also apply to traffic that transits > through the UK? Several of my providers out of Ireland have PoPs in > London that are part of the path. My reading is that any network operator can be ordered to do pretty much anything (even, as written, things that might

Re: [uknof] BT's new 1Gb/s FTTP service - any smaller ISPs to offer it?

2016-11-09 Thread William Waites
> Well we could but paying ~40quid/Mb/s (vs 0.50quid for global transit) for > the backhaul > makes it a bit useless so unless TT/others offer it wholesale with some > sensibly priced > backhaul I can't see us selling any. Indeed. If I had such a house and wanted fibre to it using BT services,

Re: [uknof] Cisco IPv6 NTP on access point

2016-10-24 Thread William Waites
> anything other than a dotted quad is treated like a hostname. So, use a hostname?

[uknof] vendor-neutral json representation of firewall rules...

2016-06-07 Thread William Waites
... does anyone know of such a beast? -w + William Waites : School of Informatics Synthsys Centre for Mammalian Synthetic Biology : University of Edinburgh

Re: [uknof] IPv6 and flat /48's

2016-05-26 Thread William Waites
Robert McKay writes: > their configuration is probably fine for a small office with a single > network. Well, no, not really. If it is a small office with a single network, there is no reason to give it a /48, it just needs a /64. And there is nno reason that I can think of to *ever* configure

Re: [uknof] IPv6 and flat /48's

2016-05-26 Thread William Waites
Brian Candler writes: > I have now dealt with two UK providers who, when asked to add IPv6 to a > business connection, have insisted on configuring a flat /48 on the CPE > LAN port. > > ... > > It seems broken by design to me. Am I right, or is this considered a > reasonable way to interconne

Re: [uknof] Mikrotik as Service Provider Router

2016-05-16 Thread William Waites
dopt such a design. As it is, where we take full tables it is BIRD on FreeBSD which is rock solid. Cheers, -w ----+ William Waites : School of Informat

Re: [uknof] Investigatory Powers Bill

2015-11-16 Thread William Waites
. And any semi-competent criminal will very quickly figure out what safe end to end encryption software to use. There's lots more. But to summarise, the law is buggy, even if it weren't it wouldn't work and it would be very expensive both in terms of operational cost and s

Re: [uknof] Notice of Claimed Infringement

2015-09-14 Thread William Waites
On Mon, 14 Sep 2015 11:12:29 +0100, Paul Mansfield said: > how would you ensure that the message, if in HTML, didn't have > some sort of tracking URL/beacon in it which could allow the > rights holder to discover your customer's IP and thus go on a > fishing trip? Please don't g

Re: [uknof] Notice of Claimed Infringement

2015-09-14 Thread William Waites
so that hopefully they can try to not do things that create work for me. Under no circumstances short of a (local) court order would I ever give any information to the media companies. -w -- William Waites | School of Informatics http://tardis.ed.ac.uk/~wwaites/ | Unive

Re: [uknof] Notice of Claimed Infringement

2015-09-13 Thread William Waites
to be worth it... -w -- William Waites | School of Informatics http://tardis.ed.ac.uk/~wwaites/ | University of Edinburgh https://hubs.net.uk/ | HUBS AS60241 The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in Scotland, with registration numb

Re: [uknof] US CLEC?

2015-06-14 Thread William Waites
On Sun, 14 Jun 2015 07:40:06 +, Ryan Finnesey said: > I apologize for what may be a very basic question but within the > UK in there something that is similar to a US CLEC? loosely, "one who unbundles bt exchanges"

Re: [uknof] VyOS 1.1.0 (helium) on Dell PowerEdge R710 - BGP Edge Router

2015-03-26 Thread William Waites
uration is all done by editing a file, but I'd be more > than happy to offer advice and assistance if need be. I second this. BIRD on (appropriately tuned) FreeBSD is rock solid, we've been doing this for several years. -w -- William Waites | School of Informatics

Re: [uknof] BGP Communities with 32-bit ASN

2015-03-17 Thread William Waites
em... -w -- William Waites | School of Informatics http://tardis.ed.ac.uk/~wwaites/ | University of Edinburgh The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in Scotland, with registration number SC005336. pgpaN0FiSiwAN.pgp Description: PGP signature

Re: [uknof] Data Retention and Public Wifi

2014-12-11 Thread William Waites
On Thu, 11 Dec 2014 15:32:01 +, "Neil J. McRae" said: > How are you engaged in this project? Are they not going to > tender it? I should have been clearer about this. I'm not directly involved in any way. I'm not bidding, and I don't work for the council. My only vested interest is a

Re: [uknof] Data Retention and Public Wifi

2014-12-11 Thread William Waites
On Thu, 11 Dec 2014 12:23:26 +, Zoe O'Connell said: > Unless you have been served with a notice, you are under no > direct legal obligation to keep any data. Yes, but here we are dealing with civil servants who will perversely want to take on as many obligations as possible to ward

[uknof] Data Retention and Public Wifi

2014-12-11 Thread William Waites
Does anyone have some good pointers about what is exactly required of a service providing (presumanly "free" for some values of free like Aberdeen is doing and Edinburgh is planning) public Wifi? And how the minimum standard can be met while avoiding intrusiveness? How does this interact operation

Re: [uknof] UK IPv6 Taskforce

2014-09-05 Thread William Waites
On 05/09/14 17:15, Neil J. McRae wrote: I think we are stuck in the time warp of 5 years ago. Its simple to > make CGN scale - the question is whether you want to or not I don't know about you, but I want the Internet to be a fundamentally asymmetric place where consumers know their place and a

Re: [uknof] NCA: Two-week opportunity for UK to reduce threat from powerful computer attack

2014-06-02 Thread William Waites
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 > "The NCA is today urging members of the public to protect themselves > against powerful malicious software (malware), which may be costing UK > computer users millions of pounds. I guess this is a good time to plug the Reset the Net campaign

Re: [uknof] Wholesale subscriber campaigns

2013-05-17 Thread William Waites
On Fri, 17 May 2013 18:45:23 +, "Neil J. McRae" said: > With a phone number or a postcode. In many of the areas where the last mile is done with wireless (the West coast of Scotland for example) this is insufficiently granular. That said, in many of these areas community networking proj