Re: [UC] Scale and its adjudicators (Was: Re: Did anyone see this from the DP?)

2008-09-27 Thread UNIVERSITY*CITOYEN
Anthony West wrote: SHCA's warrant doesn't reach east of 40th St. false. it goes east to 38th street. http://www.sprucehillca.org/map.html the rest of your post, like phc and pcpc and shca, simply ignores the height and scale issue of the proposed hotel. the hotel's massive height and

[UC] Scale and its adjudicators (Was: Re: Did anyone see this from the DP?)

2008-09-25 Thread Anthony West
Very, very interesting question, that deserves at least a stab at an answer. Scale couldn't have much of an issue when the Campus Inn went before the Historical Commission. HC's reasoning is opaque to me, but in general it seems not to be a body that deals with scale. The HC is about the