Re: [uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-23 Thread Jim Thompson
Eric, Probably just a local UW-Madison issue, but in case you forgot... If we continue to use our .../entities/channel/map-cvs-branched-env-files.xml we need to distinguish that from the actual channel files. JimT On Mar 21, 2011, at 4:00 PM, Eric Dalquist wrote: If we remove it we would

Re: [uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-21 Thread Cris J Holdorph
If you're going to rename them, is there a significant reason to even leave the '.channel' in the middle? To me this always felt like an unneeded complication when the 'type' was in the XML content to begin with. And in the case of uPortals own set of entity files it has them in

Re: [uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-21 Thread Eric Dalquist
If we remove it we would have to do one of two things. 1. Absolutely require the directory structure currently in use be used ALL the time. 2. Parse all the XML files twice, once to determine the root element and sort the data files then again to do the import. The order that the data is

Re: [uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-21 Thread Cris J Holdorph
Having information required in the 'middle' of a filename is very non-standard. So, if we can't remove it at all, then I guess I am not in favor of renaming them at all. Seeing foo.channel I'm more inclined to think I have to keep the file named *.channel. If I see a file named

Re: [uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-21 Thread Steve Swinsburg
I can see the benefit of retaining the identifier and adding the .xml extension. So we'll end up with files like: foo.channel.xml foo.channel-type.xml foo.group_membership.xml foo.fragment-layout.xml Sounds good to me. It is non-standard but means there is more clarity around what type of file

[uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-14 Thread Eric Dalquist
Anyone have any thoughts on renaming the entity files in trunk by adding .xml to the end? So IdentitySwapper.channel would become IdentitySwapper.channel.xml I think it might back life a little easier if editors recognize these files as XML by default. -Eric smime.p7s Description: S/MIME

Re: [uportal-dev] Rename entity files to entity.type.xml

2011-03-14 Thread Susan Bramhall
+1 All those type names as file name extensions is a pain. Susan On 3/14/2011 9:26 PM, Carroll, Timothy Dale wrote: +1 On Mar 14, 2011, at 8:46 PM, Eric Dalquisteric.dalqu...@doit.wisc.edu wrote: Anyone have any thoughts on renaming the entity files in trunk by adding .xml to the end?