Re: FLIP-16, FLIP-15 Status Updates?

2019-02-21 Thread Paris Carbone
I created these FLIPs a while back, sorry for being late to this discussion but I can try to elaborate. The idea from FLIP-16 is proven to be correct [1] (see chapter 3) and I think it is the only way to go but I have been in favour of providing channel implementations with checkpoint

Re: FLIP-16, FLIP-15 Status Updates?

2019-02-21 Thread Stephan Ewen
Hi John! I know some committers are working on iterations, but on a bigger update. That might subsume the FLIPs 15 and 16 eventually. I believe they will share some part of that soon (in a few weeks). Best, Stephan On Tue, Feb 19, 2019 at 5:45 PM John Tipper wrote: > Hi Timo, > > That’s

Re: FLIP-16, FLIP-15 Status Updates?

2019-02-19 Thread John Tipper
Hi Timo, That’s great, thank you very much. If I’d like to contribute, is it best to wait until the roadmap has been published? And is this the best list to ask on, or is the development mailing list better? Many thanks, John Sent from my iPhone > On 19 Feb 2019, at 16:29, Timo Walther

Re: FLIP-16, FLIP-15 Status Updates?

2019-02-19 Thread Timo Walther
Hi John, you are right that there was not much progress in the last years around these two FLIPs. Mostly due to shift of priorities. However, with the big Blink code contribution from Alibaba and joint development forces for a unified batch and streaming runtime [1], it is very likely that

FLIP-16, FLIP-15 Status Updates?

2019-02-19 Thread John Tipper
Hi All, Does anyone know what the current status is for FLIP-16 (loop fault tolerance) and FLIP-15 (redesign iterations) please? I can see lots of work back in 2016, but it all seemed to stop and go quiet since about March 2017. I see iterations as offering very interesting capabilities for