Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-05-01 Thread Stack
Update. I seem to be over the bulk of my difficulty getting thrift/rest to behave in the hadoop3/jdk11 context though there are still some stragglers. Because of this I am thinking of doing the move after 2.3.x, for 2.4.x, instead. I'll run the scenario Josh suggests of an hbase-connectors release

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-27 Thread Nick Dimiduk
On Fri, Apr 24, 2020 at 22:06 Sean Busbey wrote: > By "works with it" do you mean has documented steps to work with it or do > you mean that the convenience binary that ships for 2.3.0 will have the > same deployment model as prior 2.y releases where I can run those services > directly from the d

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-27 Thread Esteban Gutierrez
+1 But it would be great if we can deprecate their presence of those modules first in 2.3 thanks, esteban. -- Cloudera, Inc. On Mon, Apr 27, 2020 at 11:44 AM Josh Elser wrote: > +1 to the idea, -0 to the implied execution > > I agree hbase-connectors is a better place for REST and thrift, l

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-27 Thread Josh Elser
+1 to the idea, -0 to the implied execution I agree hbase-connectors is a better place for REST and thrift, long term. My concern is that I read this thread as suggesting: 1. Remove rest/thrift from 2.3 1a. Proceed with 2.3.0 rc's 2. Add rest/thrift to hbase-connectors ... n. Release hbase-conn

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-25 Thread Stack
On Fri, Apr 24, 2020 at 10:06 PM Sean Busbey wrote: > By "works with it" do you mean has documented steps to work with it or do > you mean that the convenience binary that ships for 2.3.0 will have the > same deployment model as prior 2.y releases where I can run those services > directly from th

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-25 Thread Jan Hentschel
+1 From: "张铎(Duo Zhang)" Reply-To: "d...@hbase.apache.org" Date: Saturday, April 25, 2020 at 3:20 AM To: HBase Dev List Cc: Hbase-User Subject: Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project? +1. Andrew Purtell mailto:apurt...@apac

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-24 Thread Sean Busbey
By "works with it" do you mean has documented steps to work with it or do you mean that the convenience binary that ships for 2.3.0 will have the same deployment model as prior 2.y releases where I can run those services directly from the download? On Fri, Apr 24, 2020, 16:34 Stack wrote: > Taki

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-24 Thread Duo Zhang
+1. Andrew Purtell 于2020年4月25日周六 上午5:50写道: > +1 > Let's do it. > > On Fri, Apr 24, 2020 at 2:34 PM Stack wrote: > > > Taking a sounding > > > > We've talked of moving the hbase-rest and hbase-thrift modules out of > core > > over to hbase-connectors project [2, 3]. The connectors project [1

Re: DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-24 Thread Andrew Purtell
+1 Let's do it. On Fri, Apr 24, 2020 at 2:34 PM Stack wrote: > Taking a sounding > > We've talked of moving the hbase-rest and hbase-thrift modules out of core > over to hbase-connectors project [2, 3]. The connectors project [1] was > meant for the likes of REST and thrift. I'm thinking of

DISCUSS: Move hbase-thrift and hbase-rest out of core to hbase-connectors project?

2020-04-24 Thread Stack
Taking a sounding We've talked of moving the hbase-rest and hbase-thrift modules out of core over to hbase-connectors project [2, 3]. The connectors project [1] was meant for the likes of REST and thrift. I'm thinking of trying to do the move in the next few days BEFORE 2.3.0RC0. Any objection