Re: Phoenix 4 to 5 Upgrade Path

2019-06-15 Thread James Taylor
The data format is not different between 4.0 and 5.0. The metadata can change, though. We make a best effort for a seamless, automatic upgrade, but you should test your specific scenario yourself to be confident that there are no problems. The larger the version difference, the greater the risk.

Re: Phoenix 4 to 5 Upgrade Path

2019-06-14 Thread Josh Elser
IIRC, the guidance is that 4.14 should work back to 4.12. We're talking about minor releases in this case, not bugfix. Every bugfix release should be compatible within the current minor release. This is one of the tenants of https://semver.org/ You should not have issues going to 5.0.0, but I

Re: Phoenix 4 to 5 Upgrade Path

2019-06-14 Thread Vova Galchenko
Hey Josh, thanks for getting back to me. The current Phoenix version we're on is 4.14.1. Do I understand correctly that the Phoenix community intends to provide data compatibility at least two versions back? Does this intention apply across major version boundaries? More specifically, does it

Re: Phoenix 4 to 5 Upgrade Path

2019-06-12 Thread Josh Elser
What version of Phoenix 4 are you coming from? Of note, if you're lagging far behind, you'll get bit by the column encoding turning on by default in 4.10 [1] In general, before we update the system catalog table, we take a snapshot of it, so you can roll back (although this would be manual).

Phoenix 4 to 5 Upgrade Path

2019-06-11 Thread Vova Galchenko
Hello Phoenix Users List! We at Box are thinking about the upgrade story from Phoenix 4 to 5. As part of that, we'd like to understand if these Phoenix versions write data in formats compatible with each other. In other words, suppose we have an HBase 1.4 cluster used by Phoenix 4. Can I shut