Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-21 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Jonathan Revusky wrote: I guess you and I think quite differently about certain things. In another part of this discussion, you mentioned malice as a reason not to give people commit access on an "on-demand" basis. However, this is something that hardly oc

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-21 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Jonathan Revusky wrote: Well, have you considered the positional issues I raised in the earlier post? The order in which people vote is quite important. Offhand, here is an idea: You know, I meant to address that and I completely forgot :) I think you do raise a

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-20 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Jonathan Revusky wrote: Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Welcome Jonathan! Better late than never :) Jonathan Revusky wrote: Well, to put it another way, if I were assigned the task of evaluating different things in this space, and Struts was one of them, it is very unlikely that I would settle

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-20 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Welcome Jonathan! Better late than never :) Jonathan Revusky wrote: I think here we have to agree to disagree. I see there being a responsibility involved that you don't. It isn't like anyone can just come along and contribute, contrary to what we

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-20 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Jonathan Revusky wrote: A third point that I must make in this context is that, though, in the above, I am criticizing the "electoral democracy" aspects of this, I actually don't subscribe to the idea that an open source project is a one man-one vote d

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-20 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Craig McClanahan wrote: On 3/19/06, Jonathan Revusky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: You say this as if it is the most obvious thing in the world. But is it? I am quite skeptical. You take as a given that commit privileges have to be closely guarded, like a high priesthood guards the inner s

Re: has struts reached the saturation

2006-03-19 Thread Jonathan Revusky
#x27;t know how other people see things. This is just my honest reaction. I have no vested interest in this. Regards, Jonathan Revusky -- lead developer, FreeMarker project, http://freemarker.org/ But, being part of that necessary barrier too is part of the responsibility, at least as I view thi

<    1   2