Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-19 Thread john wendel
On 09/19/2010 03:49 PM, James McKenzie wrote: >On 9/18/10 8:43 AM, Alessandro Boggiano wrote: >> I have to buy a second hand laptop and I have to choose between two >> Dell laptops! >> They are almost the same the only big difference is the video card: >> one has Nvidia 8600M GT 512MB and the

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-19 Thread James McKenzie
On 9/19/10 6:32 PM, Suvayu Ali wrote: > > In my experience, with the newer chipsets the proprietary drivers are > probably needed for both manufacturers. But for older chipsets, I would > prefer having an ATI with FOSS drivers. And remember, all chipsets will > be old someday. > That my friend is

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-19 Thread Suvayu Ali
On Sunday 19 September 2010 04:41 PM, James McKenzie wrote: > How about 2D performance for something like OpenOffice.org? Would it > still be better to get the ATI chipset vice the nVidia one or is it > neutral at that point? > I use an nVIDIA Quadro with Ubuntu Lucid at work and the Radeon HD a

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-19 Thread James McKenzie
On 9/19/10 4:30 PM, Suvayu Ali wrote: > On Sunday 19 September 2010 03:49 PM, James McKenzie wrote: >> Get the laptop with the nVidia card. Their drivers are much better than >> AMDs (Catalyst 10.7 broke a bunch of things.) >> > That is assuming the OP wants to use proprietary drivers. True. Ho

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-19 Thread Suvayu Ali
On Sunday 19 September 2010 03:49 PM, James McKenzie wrote: > Get the laptop with the nVidia card. Their drivers are much better than > AMDs (Catalyst 10.7 broke a bunch of things.) > That is assuming the OP wants to use proprietary drivers. As far as I see, the OP's options include relatively o

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-19 Thread James McKenzie
On 9/18/10 8:43 AM, Alessandro Boggiano wrote: > I have to buy a second hand laptop and I have to choose between two > Dell laptops! > They are almost the same the only big difference is the video card: > one has Nvidia 8600M GT 512MB and the other has a Radeon > ATI HD3650 256 MB. > My goal is

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-18 Thread JD
On 09/18/2010 11:50 AM, Alessandro Boggiano wrote: > Thank Bruno for the tip! > Unfortunately I can try un usb stick on them! > I can rely only on the experience of this list. :) If your bios supports booting off of external media like usb storage, or firewire storage or even external sata storag

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-18 Thread Alessandro Boggiano
Thank Bruno for the tip! Unfortunately I can try un usb stick on them! I can rely only on the experience of this list. :) 2010/9/18 Bruno Wolff III : > On Sat, Sep 18, 2010 at 17:43:35 +0200, >  Alessandro Boggiano wrote: >> I have to buy a second hand laptop and I have to choose between two >>

Re: Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-18 Thread Bruno Wolff III
On Sat, Sep 18, 2010 at 17:43:35 +0200, Alessandro Boggiano wrote: > I have to buy a second hand laptop and I have to choose between two > Dell laptops! > They are almost the same the only big difference is the video card: > one has Nvidia 8600M GT 512MB and the other has a Radeon > ATI HD3650

Radeon ATI HD3650 or Nvidia 8600M GT

2010-09-18 Thread Alessandro Boggiano
I have to buy a second hand laptop and I have to choose between two Dell laptops! They are almost the same the only big difference is the video card: one has Nvidia 8600M GT 512MB and the other has a Radeon ATI HD3650 256 MB. My goal is soft video editing and normal use (web, office...) and of cou