Re: [OMPI users] MPI_Reduce performance

2010-09-10 Thread Richard Treumann
The difference is that MPI_Barrier or even MPI_Ibarrier is a crude tool for the job. It is likely to leave resources idle that could be doing productive work. I agree it is part of the tool kit but if this kind of problem is significant enough so a textbook should cover it then I would advocate

Re: [OMPI users] MPI_Reduce performance

2010-09-10 Thread Eugene Loh
Richard Treumann wrote: Hi Ashley I understand the problem with descriptor flooding can be serious in an application with unidirectional data dependancy. Perhaps we have a different perception of how common that is. Ashley speculated it was a "significant minority."  I don't know

Re: [OMPI users] MPI_Reduce performance

2010-09-10 Thread Richard Treumann
Hi Ashley I understand the problem with descriptor flooding can be serious in an application with unidirectional data dependancy. Perhaps we have a different perception of how common that is. It seems to me that such programs would be very rare but if they are more common than I imagine, then