[Pw_forum] phonon calculation for optimized geometry -one subtle confusion

2010-04-19 Thread mohnish pandey
Yea dear Linh, I have used the converged cell parameter from vc-relax calculation for scf run, Thnaks, mohnish On Sun, Apr 18, 2010 at 8:33 PM, Ngoc Linh Nguyen wrote: > > > Dear Hanyu ! > > Thanks for your reply. As you now the default value > > for > > the pressure in PWS

[Pw_forum] phonon calculation for optimized geometry -one subtle confusion

2010-04-18 Thread Paolo Giannozzi
On Apr 18, 2010, at 13:30 , mohnish pandey wrote: > when I am doing scf calculation with the geometrical parameters > value obtained from the vc-relax calculation the pressure value is > different from vc-relax final run. as explained a diverging number of times (even recently): the plane-wave b

[Pw_forum] phonon calculation for optimized geometry

2010-04-18 Thread Hanyu
dear mohnish : I think you should check it carefully again. I don't think it should be happen. In fact, the stress of scf and vc-relax should be the same. but if the stress is not the hydrostatic pressure, the result is not be believed. you have to relax the structure until the stress of the phase

[Pw_forum] phonon calculation for optimized geometry -one subtle confusion

2010-04-18 Thread Ngoc Linh Nguyen
> Dear Hanyu ! > Thanks for your reply. As you now the default value > for > the pressure in PWSCF is 0.5. This value should be 0.0 as the default value (see in input PW website) > I am using that value as convergence > threshold > but when I am doing scf calculation with th

[Pw_forum] phonon calculation for optimized geometry -one subtle confusion

2010-04-18 Thread mohnish pandey
Dear Hanyu ! Thanks for your reply. As you now the default value for the pressure in PWSCF is 0.5. I am using that value as convergence threshold but when I am doing scf calculation with the geometrical parameters value obtained from the vc-relax calculation the pressure value

[Pw_forum] phonon calculation for optimized geometry

2010-04-18 Thread mohnish pandey
Dear users, I want to do phonon calculation for some structures, but after geometry optimization when I am using optimized geometry parameters for scf calculation there is difference in stress of scf calculation and vc-relax calculation which is changing phonon dispersion. Can any