[Pw_forum] vc-relax or relax

2009-08-20 Thread lan haiping
Hi, Ali. I learned from some literature that Only ion-relaxation should be done if you want to examine defects' properties. You can find a book " Theory of Defects in Semiconductors" which has thorough discussion over this issue . Hope help. Regards On Thu, Aug 20, 2009 at 8:27 PM, ali kazempo

[Pw_forum] vc-relax or relax

2009-08-20 Thread Lorenzo Paulatto
In data 20 agosto 2009 alle ore 14:27:40, ali kazempour ha scritto: > I make 72 atom supercell to study the effect of vacancy on defect > formation energy. If I remove one atom do I run vc-relax or relax > calculation only? I mean is this concentratio(1/72=0.013) high that > affect the la

[Pw_forum] vc-relax or relax

2009-08-20 Thread Duy Le
Hi, It's not easy to tell unless you do your own test. Try to do your calculation with many different concentration (increase the size of cell) and compare the properties that are well-known (bondlength, formation energy...). In practice, the concentration of vacancies maybe about ZERO, my point i

[Pw_forum] vc-relax or relax

2009-08-20 Thread ali kazempour
Dear All I make 72 atom supercell to study the effect of vacancy on defect formation energy. If I remove one atom do I run vc-relax or relax calculation only? I mean is this concentratio(1/72=0.013) high that affect? the lattice constant also or not? thanks a lot ? Ali Kazempour Physics depart