Re: [QE-users] NON CONVERGENCE OF PHONON CALCULATION DUE TO LIMITED NUMBER OF ITERATIONSR

2018-10-04 Thread Duc-Long Nguyen
Dear Shuham, After modifying maxter from 100 to 300, you should recompile ph.x (type make in folder PHonon/PH) as I can see the loop stopped after 100 iterations. Adding to those comments from Dr. Mattioli and Dr. Wolf, you may want to reduce 'alpha_mix' to get better convergence. H.T.H

Re: [QE-users] NON CONVERGENCE OF PHONON CALCULATION DUE TO LIMITED NUMBER OF ITERATIONSR

2018-10-04 Thread Giuseppe Mattioli
On top of this: 1) Did you relax your system with pw.x (calculation='relax')? In order to have meaningful frequencies and smooth convergence with DFPT you should stay very close to the energy minimum. 2) ecutwfc = 60.0 It might be too low for your norm-conserving B pseudopotential. Have

Re: [QE-users] NON CONVERGENCE OF PHONON CALCULATION DUE TO LIMITED NUMBER OF ITERATIONSR

2018-10-04 Thread Christoph Wolf
At first glance your system is 2-dimensional but you sample out-of plane for ph.in (q3=3). try an appropriate q-mesh such as 3x3x1, 5x5x1, ... You can see that the convergence problem occurs at a q-point that is out of plane: q = ( 0.000 0.000 0.1059000 ) HTH,

Re: [QE-users] NON CONVERGENCE OF PHONON CALCULATION DUE TO LIMITED NUMBER OF ITERATIONSR

2018-10-04 Thread Shubham Tyagi
Respected Sir/Ma'am I am Shubham Tyagi. I m currently pursuing masters in science(Physics) from IIT Jodhpur, India. I have taken DFT as my topic for my second-year project. Now I am facing some difficulties regarding that. The difficulty is summed as: I was doing phonon calculation for a

Re: [QE-users] NON CONVERGENCE OF PHONON CALCULATION DUE TO LIMITED NUMBER OF ITERATIONSR

2018-10-04 Thread Giuseppe Mattioli
Dear Colleague First of all please sign your posts to this forum with name and scientific affiliation. It's impossible to help you if you do not provide any detail of your calculation. pw.x and ph.x input files are necessary to check if one (among many) critical parameter is likely

[QE-users] NON CONVERGENCE OF PHONON CALCULATION DUE TO LIMITED NUMBER OF ITERATIONSR

2018-10-04 Thread Shubham Tyagi
Respected Sir/Ma'am I was doing phonon calculation for a supercell and I encountered with a problem that the calculations did not converge as the maximum iteration was till 100 only. I tried changing the maxter from 100 to 300 but all in vain. This all was for phonon calculation. So can you