Re: [strongSwan] seeking advice: pfs on creating a child_sa?

2016-03-08 Thread John Brown
Hi Harrii, I can give you only an opinion of strongswan user but this is not an opinion of cryptographic expert. I think that using pfs for child_sa is not critical issue but it is better to use it if you can. If you do not use pfs for phase 2 crypto keys for this phase are derived from other

Re: [strongSwan] seeking advice: pfs on creating a child_sa?

2016-03-04 Thread Harald Dunkel
Hi John, On 03/01/2016 12:55 PM, John Brown wrote: > Hi, > > I can give you two links with some small amount information about your > question: > > http://www.juniper.net/documentation/en_US/junos12.1x46/topics/concept/vpn-security-phase-2-ipsec-proposal-understanding.html > > and > >

Re: [strongSwan] seeking advice: pfs on creating a child_sa?

2016-03-04 Thread ValdikSS
I'd also like someone to clarify this question. From what I understand currently, using EDH for IKE_SA is a PFS as it is in "usual" SSL/TLS (e.g. in HTTPS) — you'll get new EDH key for every new IKE_SA negotiation. But EDH in CHILD_SA is what you would call "key rotation". If you use EDH in

Re: [strongSwan] seeking advice: pfs on creating a child_sa?

2016-03-01 Thread John Brown
Hi, I can give you two links with some small amount information about your question: http://www.juniper.net/documentation/en_US/junos12.1x46/topics/concept/vpn-security-phase-2-ipsec-proposal-understanding.html and

[strongSwan] seeking advice: pfs on creating a child_sa?

2016-03-01 Thread Harald Dunkel
Hi folks, looking for some advice: Would you suggest to use pfs for esp? Apparently pfs is a must-have to establish an ike_sa today, but is this reasonable for the child_sas as well? Every helpful comment is highly appreciated Harri ___ Users mailing