Re: Solr 10 should be a big bang release

2025-09-06 Thread Gus Heck
Hmm, the threading on this is probably unclear. The last message was in response to "Making zookeeper optional would go a long way for user goodwill and adoption." On Sat, Sep 6, 2025 at 9:19 PM Gus Heck wrote: > This is one of those things I find perpetually amusing and I blame it > mostly on

Re: Solr 10 should be a big bang release

2025-09-06 Thread Ishan Chattopadhyaya
> Your list has cool stuff but I think mostly can ship at whatever minor version. Solr has seen incremental progress over the years at minor releases. If we don't ship headline grabbing features in a major release, we might as well abandon this project and dedicate our focus on building OpenSearch

Re: Solr 10 should be a big bang release

2025-09-06 Thread Gus Heck
This is one of those things I find perpetually amusing and I blame it mostly on insufficient documentation *in solr docs* for securing and configuring ZK. Every large Elastic/ES cluster has an odd number of dedicated master nodes ... which is analogous to having a zookeeper cluster (the classic exa

Re: Solr 10 should be a big bang release

2025-09-06 Thread Gus Heck
I agree with a lot of these goals, but I have long felt that the place where we are likely to lose ground is the ecosystem (things like what is in the "general" list). - Good UI - Good Document Ingestion Solutions - Documented Standardized Monitoring... - Solid Authorization implementa