Re: can you trust the MX?

2007-01-30 Thread Raul Dias
On Mon, 2007-01-29 at 21:03 +0100, Magnus Holmgren wrote: > So, it is well established that mail from a domain doesn't have to be sent > from the MX for the domain. But the converse should be true, shouldn't it? > I.e. an MX for a domain is normally a legitimate deliverer of mail from that > do

Re: can you trust the MX?

2007-01-30 Thread Kenneth Porter
--On Monday, January 29, 2007 9:03 PM +0100 Magnus Holmgren <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: So, it is well established that mail from a domain doesn't have to be sent from the MX for the domain. But the converse should be true, shouldn't it? I.e. an MX for a domain is normally a legitimate deliver

Re: can you trust the MX?

2007-01-29 Thread Magnus Holmgren
On Monday 29 January 2007 15:01, Matt Kettler wrote: > Mike Jackson wrote: > > Shouldn't mail be sent through the MX for a domain? > > Not if the domain is of any decent size.. Using different servers for > outbound vs inbound mail is a very common load balancing tactic for > large sites. > > Which

Re: can you trust the MX?

2007-01-29 Thread Benny Pedersen
On Mon, January 29, 2007 14:38, Mike Jackson wrote: > Before my actual question, here's a little background. Right now, I see how > pointless SPF is; few domains publish records, even fewer MTAs running in > the wild use SPF to accept/reject mail. When I look at the SPF scoring on my > server (whe

Re: can you trust the MX?

2007-01-29 Thread Matt Kettler
Mike Jackson wrote: > Before my actual question, here's a little background. Right now, I > see how pointless SPF is; few domains publish records, even fewer MTAs > running in the wild use SPF to accept/reject mail. When I look at the > SPF scoring on my server (where I'm running an SPF milter for

can you trust the MX?

2007-01-29 Thread Mike Jackson
Before my actual question, here's a little background. Right now, I see how pointless SPF is; few domains publish records, even fewer MTAs running in the wild use SPF to accept/reject mail. When I look at the SPF scoring on my server (where I'm running an SPF milter for Sendmail), most of the ma