RE: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread Andreas Tscharner
So what is the proper way to continuously perform the workflow we're trying to do - that is pull changes from origin path into branch, push changes to origin branch from branch, and repeat. Using bidirectional merge (without reintegrate) seems create severe merge conflicts. Short answer:

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread Stefan Sperling
On Sun, Feb 24, 2013 at 12:14:04PM +, Andreas Tscharner wrote: So what is the proper way to continuously perform the workflow we're trying to do - that is pull changes from origin path into branch, push changes to origin branch from branch, and repeat. Using bidirectional merge

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread James Hanley
Yes I have used git, etc - in the past, but we are forced to use svn for the time being. What I would like to quantify is if this shortcoming of subversion is by design or if its a bug. From your description, it seems like the former, and if so, what is the architectural reasoning? I understand

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread James Hanley
I guess I should have read the next response in the thread before replying... On Feb 24, 2013, at 7:52 AM, Stefan Sperling s...@elego.de wrote: On Sun, Feb 24, 2013 at 12:14:04PM +, Andreas Tscharner wrote: So what is the proper way to continuously perform the workflow we're trying to do

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread Stefan Sperling
On Sun, Feb 24, 2013 at 07:55:41AM -0500, James Hanley wrote: Is this a use case that was taken into consideration, and will it be fixed or the functionality/logic added to allow this use case? See my other reply for more details, but yes, this is being addressed:

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread Stefan Sperling
On Sun, Feb 24, 2013 at 07:57:14AM -0500, James Hanley wrote: I guess I should have read the next response in the thread before replying... So, to be clear (since you asked off-list): The following changes to your script prevent the tree conflict with 1.7. --- enduceTreeConflict.sh.orig Sun

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread James Hanley
Okay - I read through and understand the use of reintegrate - but that is what we are using and the script provided in the original post uses. The issue is that even with its use, I'm getting a tree conflict. Please read and test the script from the original post. On Feb 24, 2013, at 7:59 AM,

Re: Merge, reintegrate, and merge with tree conflicts

2013-02-24 Thread James Hanley
Okay - I read through and understand the use of reintegrate - but that is what we are using and the script provided in the original post uses. The issue is that even with its use, I'm getting a tree conflict. Please read and test the script from the original post. Meant to reply all (twice) On