Yeah, same here on JAAS - it's good for locking parts of the codebase
if you really needed to but way too cumbersome for web app security.
Heh, as the committer and maintainer both in Tynamo and Shiro, I kind
of have to recommend them.
Kalle
On Wed, Jun 1, 2011 at 2:35 PM, Lenny Primak wrote:
>
The closest to CMA that I've used was JAAS. I didn't like it. Sounds like you
are recommending tynamo and shiro.
On Jun 1, 2011, at 5:19 PM, Kalle Korhonen wrote:
> I see - should have said I assume you are using CMA. I'm biased of
> course, but when ever I've used CMA, I've found it too cum
I see - should have said I assume you are using CMA. I'm biased of
course, but when ever I've used CMA, I've found it too cumbersome and
limiting.
Kalle
On Wed, Jun 1, 2011 at 2:03 PM, Lenny Primak wrote:
> Thanks! I am not using CMA actually, it is JSP home-grown security,
> which I am lookin
Thanks! I am not using CMA actually, it is JSP home-grown security,
which I am looking to replace.
In your opinion, should I look use CMA or go with tynamo & shiro?
I guess I can do a bake-off but I would rather not.
On Jun 1, 2011, at 4:29 PM, Kalle Korhonen wrote:
> The big three for Java ar
Keep in mind that Tynamo's security package is Apache Shiro
(http://shiro.apache.org/) with additions that make it easy to work
with Tapestry. If you want something that isn't Tapestry specific,
take a look at Shiro by itself.
If you are wanting other Tapestry options, look at:
http://code.google.
The big three for Java are CMA (Container Managed Authentication)
which you are using, Spring Security (ex-Acegi Security, Tapestry
integration provided by tapestry-spring-security module) and Apache
Shiro (ex-JSecurity, Tapestry integration provided by Tynamo's
tapestry-security). I've spent more
Thanks guys I'll definitely look at tynamo security.
There is a lot of homegrown code in our implementation that feels like it
should be a part of a framework that's already been written. I guess that
tynamo security is that framework.
Anything else I should be l should be looking at in this s
Definitely look at Tynamo's tapestry-security which uses Shiro and the
tynamo-federatedaccounts add on. I believe you can have multiple
types of authentication simply by contributing different entity
realms. It has built in support for Facebook and OpenId is coming.
Mark
On Wed, Jun 1, 2011 at 1
On Wed, 01 Jun 2011 14:33:47 -0300, Lenny Primak
wrote:
My current project is to refresh a client's web site using tapestry. The
web site currently uses JSP. We have a JEE/web service backend that
uses JPA/EJB3.1 which we will continue to use.
We now have a JEE based authorization service
My current project is to refresh a client's web site using tapestry. The web
site currently uses JSP. We have a JEE/web service backend that uses
JPA/EJB3.1 which we will continue to use.
We now have a JEE based authorization service API based on plain method calls
now.
What we want is to k
10 matches
Mail list logo
