RE: [Vo]:Comments by Duncan, Celani at ICCF16

2011-02-07 Thread Jones Beene
From: albedo5 I would SO love to get a spectrum to analyse - along with detector details, of course. I really think that would tell a better story. One thing which might be helpful for future analysis, or in any experiment to confirm Rossi, even without his assistance - is to compile a

Re: [Vo]:Comments by Duncan, Celani at ICCF16

2011-02-07 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 08:58 AM 2/7/2011, Jed Rothwell wrote: Celani's description of the demo was more critical than his discussion with me, yesterday. He was quite upset that they did not let him make nuclear measurements, and I suspect that has colored his thinking. Rossi told him "we can't let you take a gamma

Re: [Vo]:Comments by Duncan, Celani at ICCF16

2011-02-07 Thread albedo5
I would SO love to get a spectrum to analyse - along with detector details, of course. I really think that would tell a better story. On Mon, Feb 7, 2011 at 12:04 PM, Jones Beene wrote: > Ø Bottom line: what signature, even if fully known, could be so > revealing that it would really matter f

RE: [Vo]:Comments by Duncan, Celani at ICCF16

2011-02-07 Thread Jones Beene
* Bottom line: what signature, even if fully known, could be so revealing that it would really matter for a patent which is already filed? OK - delayed flash of the old memory banks . . yes, there is one detail from the recent past that does come to mind, which might show up as "revealin

RE: [Vo]:Comments by Duncan, Celani at ICCF16

2011-02-07 Thread Jones Beene
Thanks to Jed for the update. There are lots of Monday morning quarterbacks around today, so hopefully a few serious ones, with expertise in a very narrow field have focused on saving-the-world from OPEC, instead of a hyped up game that only fan-boys will remember next week. (apologies to cheese-he

[Vo]:Comments by Duncan, Celani at ICCF16

2011-02-07 Thread Jed Rothwell
Rob Duncan was supposed to give one of the keynote addresses. Unfortunately, the blizzard in the U.S. shut down Chicago and he was unable to come. He e-mailed his comments and they were read by Melich. They were excellent. I hope to get a copy soon. Anyway, one thing he said was that the heat in ma