Re: [Vo]:Failure to replicate means failure to replicate

2008-10-01 Thread Steven Krivit
http://earthtech.org/experiments/DZ/DZ2.htm I need to read what the Littles did, before gabbing about this. Here I have done what I always criticize the skeptics for doing: commenting without doing my homework first! - Jed

Re: [Vo]:Failure to replicate means failure to replicate

2008-10-01 Thread Jed Rothwell
I wrote: To be fair, I should point out that as far as I know no one has replicated the latest claims by Dash & Zhang, and their method is significantly different from other cold fusion claims. Cancel that. I was thinking of Dash's earlier work with titanium sheets. I don't recall other rep

Re: [Vo]:Failure to replicate means failure to replicate

2008-10-01 Thread Jed Rothwell
[Here is a follow-up message I sent to Steve, Scott and Mike Melich.] To be fair, I should point out that as far as I know no one has replicated the latest claims by Dash & Zhang, and their method is significantly different from other cold fusion claims. So I think it is possible that they are

[Vo]:Failure to replicate means failure to replicate

2008-10-01 Thread Jed Rothwell
Here is an exchange of messages between Marissa Little, Steve Krivit, and me. - Jed - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - From: Marissa Little To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2008 5:10 PM Subject: CMNS: EarthTech's Dash-Zhang experiment Thanks to John's recent reminder, we've