Re: [Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-11 Thread Jed Rothwell
Dave Nagel says that about 100 people turned out for the memorial service. Talbott was a nice person with many friends. Daniel Rocha danieldi...@gmail.com asked: Did he have any opinion on Rossi's device? Or on Ni+H reactions in general? What was it? He seemed negative about that. I thought

Re: [Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-11 Thread Daniel Rocha
Please, I am curious. Not only about Rossi, but about Ni + H in general... 2011/12/12 Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com Did he have any opinion on Rossi's device? Or on Ni+H reactions in general? What was it? He seemed negative about that. I thought he was misinformed about the details

[Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-10 Thread Jed Rothwell
Dennis Cravens just told me: I was just informed that Talbot Chubb just passed away (Dec 10). I remember fondly of our discussions of band states and he helped get me started looking at Pd on crystals and high Gibbs free compounds. I will miss him and our monthly talks on the phone. He was a

Re: [Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-10 Thread Alan Fletcher
Sorry to hear that ... and I'd just included a batch of Chubb papers in my reading list, so he was fresh on my mind. - Original Message - Dennis Cravens just told me: I was just informed that Talbot Chubb just passed away (Dec 10). - Jed

Re: [Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-10 Thread Daniel Rocha
That's sad! His long time collaborator also passed away this year. Were they relatives since both were Chubb? BTW, his theory is the best I could find and was the most economical in using new physics, which is why it was my favorite... I am new to LENR field, but it doesn't seem people

Re: [Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-10 Thread Jed Rothwell
Daniel Rocha danieldi...@gmail.com wrote: That's sad! His long time collaborator also passed away this year. Were they relatives since both were Chubb? Talbot was Scott's uncle. He was very old. He attended his granddaughter's wedding last year. At the NRL there is a conference hall with

Re: [Vo]:Talbot Chubb dies

2011-12-10 Thread Daniel Rocha
Did he have any opinion on Rossi's device? Or on Ni+H reactions in general? What was it? 2011/12/10 Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com Daniel Rocha danieldi...@gmail.com wrote: That's sad! His long time collaborator also passed away this year. Were they relatives since both were Chubb?