Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread Gino Pacitti via Webobjects-dev
Thanks for this… Gino > On Apr 13, 2023, at 8:52 PM, René Bock wrote: > > In 2019 at the WODay, Dennis Bliefernicht presented a solution to replace > mod_webobjects, WOTaskd and WOMonitor using the traefik proxy-server . > > See https://wocommunity.org/podcasts/wowodc/2019/Deployment.mp4 > <

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread René Bock via Webobjects-dev
In 2019 at the WODay, Dennis Bliefernicht presented a solution to replace mod_webobjects, WOTaskd and WOMonitor using the traefik proxy-server . See https://wocommunity.org/podcasts/wowodc/2019/Deployment.mp4 Am 13.04.2023 um 14:29 schrieb Gino Pacitti via Webobjects-dev : I was more intere

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread Gino Pacitti via Webobjects-dev
I was more interested I how K8 could handle the instances and sessions.. I think it would be a bit difficult to deploy pods and needing to handle session traffic.REST would be a lot easier and using  session-less approach.On 13 Apr 2023, at 18:25, Jesse Tayler wrote:Um. The app is mostly session

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread Jesse Tayler via Webobjects-dev
Um. The app is mostly session stuff, there’s a few routes but I’m not thrilled with the way it is handled and you still have those pages with the weird dot notation in the URL… I use ERRest and it’s great, I’m not certain if session objects are created during requests, but it won’t have any nee

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread Gino Pacitti via Webobjects-dev
Do your build the apps using DA/REST so session-less ?Gino On 13 Apr 2023, at 17:59, Jesse Tayler via Webobjects-dev wrote:I’m using Docker for WO and like it.It controls the environment and tames our big industrial giant stuff and makes it quite manageable.On Apr 13, 2023, at 4:22 AM, Sébastien

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread Jesse Tayler via Webobjects-dev
I’m using Docker for WO and like it. It controls the environment and tames our big industrial giant stuff and makes it quite manageable. > On Apr 13, 2023, at 4:22 AM, Sébastien Rottiers via Webobjects-dev > wrote: > > Hi Oleksii, > > Very interesting blog post ! I’m very interested to move

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2023-04-13 Thread Sébastien Rottiers via Webobjects-dev
Hi Oleksii, Very interesting blog post ! I’m very interested to move our classical WebObjects deployment on AWS ec2 with auto scaling, to your Cloud-native WebObjects deployment solution. Have you some new feedback about your solution in production after some months ? Did you move to Kubernete

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-16 Thread Oleksii Serhiienko via Webobjects-dev
Hi Aaron, I have seen your email long time ago where you ask about Kubernetes, and decided to write a post :) Let me know if you have any questions best, Oleksii On Mon, Aug 15, 2022, 3:38 AM Aaron Rosenzweig wrote: > Thank you Oleksii for taking the time to write up an excellent blog post. >

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-16 Thread Oleksii Serhiienko via Webobjects-dev
Hi Tim, You are correct, it is not possible with proposed solution. It was one of the point we had to communicate to customers. But we just made a proper release calendar and being logged out wasn't the issue for users. We could implement it, but it wasn't worth the time invested. I would impleme

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-15 Thread Oleksii Serhiienko via Webobjects-dev
Hi Paul, Yes, it is written with a little bit academy language, but it is my experience from moving actually production application. In the past I completely skipped security part, but in internet there are a lot of information about docker images and docker hosts best security practices. In prod

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-15 Thread Ramsey Gurley via Webobjects-dev
Hi Oleksii, Great work and nice writeup. Since you're doing a war deployment in container, you may want to look at the maven jib plugin. Jib can build an OCI formatted tarball without docker installed at all on the machine. Furthermore, it can layer the image to minimize data transfers when dep

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-15 Thread D Tim Cummings via Webobjects-dev
Hi Oleksii, I read your post and it was great. Removing wotaskd from a deployment is enticing. One thing I can do with wotaskd/womonitor deployments is upgrade the webobjects application to a new version without taking down the application for users who are currently logged in. They continue us

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-15 Thread Paul Hoadley via Webobjects-dev
Hi Oleksii, On 15 Aug 2022, at 06:50, Oleksii Serhiienko via Webobjects-dev wrote: > In the past, I was working with a WebObjects application which was migrated > to the Cloud. > To share more findings and experience, I have created a demo application >

Re: WebObjects Docker Deployment

2022-08-14 Thread Aaron Rosenzweig via Webobjects-dev
Thank you Oleksii for taking the time to write up an excellent blog post. I skimmed it just now but I absolutely love how you crafted a story from the beginnings, of how we did deployments along with the why/how up to today with using Docker and why you did that. It sure would be nice to do it