[websec] Feedback on draft-ietf-websec-key-pinning-01

2011-12-11 Thread davidillsley
Hi all, It's good to see the progress in draft-ietf-websec-key-pinning-01. I'm still concerned about the impact of pinning on non-pinned domains, and don't see anything present to warn about or mitigate this. Apologies if I've missed discussion of this on-list/in the archives. My concern center

Re: [websec] Certificate Pinning via HSTS (.txt version)

2011-09-13 Thread davidillsley
On 13 Sep 2011, at 23:30, Marsh Ray wrote: > > Wouldn't they have to acquire a valid cert first? Not saying that's out of > the realm of possibility, but... Yeah, but in the case that you've gained control of a domains DNS, which is what happened, how hard would it be to get a valid DV cert?__

Re: [websec] Certificate Pinning via HSTS (.txt version)

2011-09-13 Thread davidillsley
On 13 Sep 2011, at 21:35, Chris Palmer wrote: > > sites; small sites may have to choose no pinning or potentially > bricking their site (up to the maxAge window). This is not worse than > the status quo.""" What about sites which don't currently use https at all? The DNS records for theregister