[whatwg] fixing the authentication problem

2008-10-21 Thread Aaron Swartz
The most common way of authenticating to web applications is: Client: GET /login Server: htmlform method=post Client: POST /login user=joesmith01password=secret Server: 200 OK Set-Cookie: acct=joesmith01,2008-10-21,sj89d89asd89s8d The obvious problem with this is that passwords are

Re: [whatwg] fixing the authentication problem

2008-10-21 Thread Aaron Swartz
As I understand it: As an attacker, I can intercept that dXN... string. Then I can simply make a login POST request myself at any time in the future, sending the same encrypted string, and will get the valid login cookies even though I don't know the password. So it doesn't seem to work very

[whatwg] List of differences between whatwg and w3c spec?

2008-09-11 Thread Aaron Swartz
I notice there are specs for HTML5 dated today at: http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/ http://www.w3.org/html/wg/html5/ diff -u shows a lot of difference, but most are cosmetic. (I gather they're there because Hixie disagrees with some W3C pubrules but can't get them changed.) Is

[whatwg] Repetition templates missing

2008-09-11 Thread Aaron Swartz
In the 11 September 2008 edition, section 1.6 of the HTML5 WD (http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/#structure) links to Repetition Templates at #repetition but there is no element with that ID. In a recent interview