Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-04-05 Thread Ian Hickson
On Tue, 5 Apr 2005, Matthew Raymond wrote: That said, this is how I would process the sample markup: body p.../p unnamed section h1A/h1 1A (importance level 1) I agree with most of what you said but the problem I have with

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-04-04 Thread Matthew Raymond
Okay, here's my two cents on the heading/section issue... The element h1 can be used in HTML4 multiple times. Therefore, it is not by default the title of a document. The most natural thing to assume is that title is the title of the document, regardless of how people might abuse it. At

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-04-04 Thread Ian Hickson
On Mon, 4 Apr 2005, Matthew Raymond wrote: That said, this is how I would process the sample markup: body p.../p unnamed section h1A/h1 1A (importance level 1) I agree with most of what you said but the problem I have with the above

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-04-04 Thread Matthew Raymond
Ian Hickson wrote: On Mon, 4 Apr 2005, Matthew Raymond wrote: That said, this is how I would process the sample markup: body p.../p unnamed section h1A/h1 1A (importance level 1) I agree with most of what you said but the problem I have with the

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-04-02 Thread Ian Hickson
On Sat, 2 Apr 2005, Matthew Thomas wrote: [titles should include more context than h1s] This requires that the site be small enough for humans to bother assembling the title in every page (rather than it being assembled by a CMS that doesn't know whether to use to or used during or in

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-04-01 Thread Ian Hickson
On Fri, 1 Apr 2005, Matthew Thomas wrote: Another example: titleIntroduction to the mating rituals of bees/title ... h1Introduction/h1 And that's an unrealistic example, because it's treating two definitions of the word Introduction as if they were the same. (As a heading

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-03-31 Thread Matthew Thomas
First, I don't understand why section 2.4 of the Web Apps spec exists -- or sections 2.3, 2.5, 2.6.2, or 2.7. None of these seem to have nothing to do with eas[ing] the authoring of Web-based applications, or even anything to do with Web-based applications at all. They would make more sense in

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-03-31 Thread fantasai
James Graham wrote: Ian Hickson wrote: I've reached the point in my ambitious attempt at defining HTML's elements for the Web Apps spec [1] where I have to define h1 - h6. There are two big issues here: 1. What do h1 to h6 mean in a body? 2. What do h1 to h6 mean in a section? Incidentially,

Re: [whatwg] h1 to h6 in body

2005-03-31 Thread Ian Hickson
On Thu, 31 Mar 2005, dolphinling wrote: Nah, section would just be explicitly part of the section-generating process. I'm just trying to get h1-h6 down before we start introducing the new elements to the mix. I mean that elements will have to be improperly nested (i.e.