Re: [Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-24 Thread Anupriya Nyayban
Dear Prof. Gavin and Prof. Marks, Thank you for clearing it to me. I have used the wrong formula ( http://webmineral.com/help/CellDimensions.shtml#.YXTy5SbhUlI) for the volume of a triclinic cell and this made me confused. -- With regards Anupriya Nyayban Ph.D. Scholar Department of Physics NIT

Re: [Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-23 Thread Laurence Marks
Also, the relevance of the results goes as exp(-time*1,000,000) so after 11 years the Professor has probably moved to another country. I am 100% certain that you are worrying about details which do not matter: a) DFT lattice parameters are rarely better than 0.5%. b) DFT energies are rarely

Re: [Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-23 Thread Gavin Abo
I follow that your lattice parameters a=18.508 Bohr, b=39.835 Bohr, c=40.199 Bohr, α=119.701 degrees, β=103.309 degrees, and γ=90.0 degrees using the equation at [1] give you Volume_triclinic = 18.508 Bohr*39.835 Bohr*40.199 Bohr*sqrt(1-cos(119.701 degrees *(π radians/180

Re: [Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-23 Thread Anupriya Nyayban
Dear Prof. Blaha and Dr. Bhamu, Thank you Prof. Blaha for the valuable suggestion and I have followed all the steps as you have mentioned for the optimization. But still I have doubt when I am going to calculate the optimized lattice parameters from the optimized volume. The initial volume

Re: [Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-22 Thread Dr. K. C. Bhamu
Dear Anupriya, I would first do a full optimization (vc-relax) in other code (VASP/QE) for such a large system and then using this fully optimized structure, I will do an ion relaxation (run_lapw -min) in Wien2k. If you want to do everything using Wien2k, please follow Prof. Peter's

Re: [Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-22 Thread Peter Blaha
A full optimization of a bigger triclinic structure is hardly possible with WIEN2k. It depends a lot on what the purpose of your calculations is, but: a) Most importantly, optimize the position of the atoms using the forces: run_lapw -min ... b) eventually I'd next do a volume

[Wien] Doubts regarding the volume optimization of a triclinic cell

2021-10-22 Thread Anupriya Nyayban
Dear users and experts, I have a triclinic structure (P1 space group) with lattice parameters a=18.508, b=39.835, c=40.199 Bohr; α = 119.701 ◦ , β = 103.309 ◦ , γ = 90.0 ◦. I have the following doubts 1) The volume obtained with these lattice parameters as well angles (with the formula for