[Wien] non-corrolated orbitals and GGA+U approximation

2012-05-16 Thread masoud majidiyan
Dear pro.Balha, we want to know if it is reasonable to use GGA+U for the non-corrolated orbitals like p orbitals? we have used GGA+U for O-2p and Zn-3d orbitals with Ud=0.98 Ry and Up=1.1Ry and in this case we obtained the band gap of ZnO ( wurtzite structure) 3.03 eV , which is very close to the

[Wien] non-corrolated orbitals and GGA+U approximation

2012-05-16 Thread Peter Blaha
With LDA+U you can do almost anything by choosing some parameters (try negative U,) and thus, if you know the experiment, you can play around and vary U of some atoms and states until you get the desired result (you could probably also use a larger U on Zn and a smaller one on O and get the

[Wien] non-corrolated orbitals and GGA+U approximation

2012-05-16 Thread t...@theochem.tuwien.ac.at
Just to be more specific: yes, the exact DFT potential would not give the correct gap. However, this statement applies for the case of orbital-independent potentials (like MBJLDA), while LDA+U is an orbital-dependent potential. On Wed, 16 May 2012, Peter Blaha wrote: With LDA+U you can do