Re: [WikiEN-l] full-text searching since the Vector switch in en.wikipedia

2010-05-21 Thread Andrew Gray
On 20 May 2010 19:19, Gregory Maxwell wrote: > If we're in a proposal mood:   Why not make it go, but if it go-es > rather than takes you to special search  put a small box of other > search results above the article. (along with your advanced button, > and an obvious close X to get rid of it if

Re: [WikiEN-l] full-text searching since the Vector switch in en.wikipedia

2010-05-20 Thread Gregory Maxwell
On Thu, May 20, 2010 at 2:10 PM, Andrew Gray wrote: > Relatedly, a proposal! > > Search box, two buttons. One, "search" or "go", acts as the old > mixed-search "go" button - it is a direct leap to that title, else > falling back on the search. The second button is "advanced"; it takes > the conten

Re: [WikiEN-l] full-text searching since the Vector switch in en.wikipedia

2010-05-20 Thread Andrew Gray
On 19 May 2010 15:51, Amir E. Aharoni wrote: > ... Yes, it makes a lot of sense that there would be such a button in > Wikipedia, because quite a lot of the people who type "obama" probably > just want the article about the president (but someone should research > how many exactly). Forcing them

Re: [WikiEN-l] full-text searching since the Vector switch in en.wikipedia

2010-05-20 Thread Ray Saintonge
Amir E. Aharoni wrote: > On Wed, May 19, 2010 at 17:40, Steve Summit wrote: > >> Carcharoth wrote: >> >>> not "search" functionality, but seeing as Google's default is >>> "search" not "go", I suspect more people are used to getting a list >>> of search results and clicking the top one tha

Re: [WikiEN-l] full-text searching since the Vector switch in en.wikipedia

2010-05-20 Thread Amir E. Aharoni
On Wed, May 19, 2010 at 17:40, Steve Summit wrote: > > Carcharoth wrote: > > I suppose the idea is that most people using that search box want > > "go" functionality, > > Many tech-savvy editors, perhaps, but certainly not most readers. > > > not "search" functionality, but seeing as Google's defa

Re: [WikiEN-l] full-text searching since the Vector switch in en.wikipedia

2010-05-19 Thread Steve Summit
Carcharoth wrote: > I suppose the idea is that most people using that search box want > "go" functionality, Many tech-savvy editors, perhaps, but certainly not most readers. > not "search" functionality, but seeing as Google's default is > "search" not "go", I suspect more people are used to gett