Re: [Wikitech-l] Shifting from PHP mailer to Swift Mailer

2014-05-25 Thread Tony Thomas
Hi, We have prepared the PS on shifting from PEAR to SwiftMailer. Please go through and review the PS here ( https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/#/c/135290/ ). As the commit message says - there are some compatibility issues like :- * Couldn't find an alternative for the 'IDHost' in

Re: [Wikitech-l] Shifting from PHP mailer to Swift Mailer

2014-05-02 Thread Tony Thomas
Hello Andre, I was indeed in search of more input whether it's a good idea or bad one. Nemo tells me it will be a nice move to shift from the conventional usermailer [1]. Since its an additional task in my proposal, I am ready to take up the shifting job, as it needs to be done first,

Re: [Wikitech-l] Shifting from PHP mailer to Swift Mailer

2014-05-01 Thread Andre Klapper
Hi Tony, could you clarify your intention for this email? Are you seeking for more input whether it's a good idea, or if this actually needed? Or are you searching for agreement as you plan to work on a patch yourself? Or are you looking for somebody to work on this? It's not entirely clear to

Re: [Wikitech-l] Shifting from PHP mailer to Swift Mailer

2014-04-29 Thread Tony Thomas
Hi, Looks like there isn't any more reply about this proposal on shifting from UserMailer to Swift-Mailer. Since, we have already started with implementing VERP, it's high time this enhancement needs to be applied, if it needs to be. If Swift-Mailer is to be done, VERP needs to be

[Wikitech-l] Shifting from PHP mailer to Swift Mailer

2014-04-04 Thread Tony Thomas
Hi, While working on implementing VERP for Mediawiki[1], Nemo pointed to me, Tyler' recommendation[2] on shifting from PHP mailer to Swift Mailer[3]. Quoting Tyler's words : PHPMailer has everything packed into a few classes, whereas Swift_Mailer actually has a separation of concerns,