Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-19 Thread Robert Shearman
Peter Beutner wrote: Dmitry Timoshkov schrieb: "Peter Beutner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Wine is a very good way of testing the waters with a Linux market. If a significant part of the market share starts coming from Linux or other Unix operating systems then the company can start offerin

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-18 Thread Dan Kegel
On 12/13/05, Dan Kegel <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > So I've been thinking about how to attract more Windows ISVs > to test, support, and promote their apps on Linux with Wine. >... > I've made a start at the documentation (http://kegel.com/wine/isv) ... > How about we create a new mailing list, win

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-18 Thread Robert Shearman
Peter Beutner wrote: Michael Jung schrieb: On Friday 16 December 2005 10:49, Peter Beutner wrote: Wine is _not_ just a different toolkit. Just look at all the "nasty" stuff wine has to do to emulate the windows process environment. I guess in the long term a project like wine, if success

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-17 Thread Scott Ritchie
On Fri, 2005-12-16 at 23:45 -0700, Vitaliy Margolen wrote: > Friday, December 16, 2005, 11:26:28 PM, Scott Ritchie wrote: > > On Fri, 2005-12-16 at 19:48 +0100, Alexandre Julliard wrote: > >> The goal is not to prevent regressions between every minor point > >> release, it's to make releases freque

Supporting ISVs (was: Create new mailing list wine-isv?)

2005-12-16 Thread Dan Kegel
Markus Goemmel wrote: > My partner and I are developing Windows applications > (http://www.emtec.com). Seeing Wine some months ago fascinated > me a lot, so since then I'm spending one or two hours a day > trying to bring our applications to work under Wine, too... > > But it's clear that there are

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Vitaliy Margolen
Friday, December 16, 2005, 11:26:28 PM, Scott Ritchie wrote: > On Fri, 2005-12-16 at 19:48 +0100, Alexandre Julliard wrote: >> The goal is not to prevent regressions between every minor point >> release, it's to make releases frequently enough that regressions can >> be found and fixed quickly, so

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Scott Ritchie
On Fri, 2005-12-16 at 19:48 +0100, Alexandre Julliard wrote: > The goal is not to prevent regressions between every minor point > release, it's to make releases frequently enough that regressions can > be found and fixed quickly, so that they don't creep into the next > major release. Now, if you t

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Alexandre Julliard
Tony Lambregts <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Perhaps it's partly a matter of perception then. > > If I understand you 0.9 was a major release then, and 0.9.1 and > company are minor releases, with the next major release being 1.0. So > I anticipate that we will have a major freeze before 1.0 jus

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Willie Sippel
Am Freitag, 16. Dezember 2005 19:48 schrieb Alexandre Julliard: > The idea is that people should test the releases. The point of the > beta phase is to encourage end users to test, and for this to happen > they need to be able to get binary packages, which is what the > releases are about. This is

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Tony Lambregts
On 12/16/05, Alexandre Julliard <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Tony Lambregts <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > > Well that is a real sore spot with me. You know that I am a strong > > supporter of wine but it really concerns me that we have gone beta and > > not addressed preventing regessions from ge

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Uwe Bonnes
> "Peter" == Peter Beutner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Peter> Michael Jung schrieb: >> On Friday 16 December 2005 15:41, Peter Beutner wrote: >>> Don't get me wrong I still think it is perfectly valid that wine is >>> doing that sort of hack to get existing windows applications

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Alexandre Julliard
Tony Lambregts <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Well that is a real sore spot with me. You know that I am a strong > supporter of wine but it really concerns me that we have gone beta and > not addressed preventing regessions from getting into our releases in > any way. We currently have no freeze or

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Peter Beutner
Michael Jung schrieb: On Friday 16 December 2005 15:41, Peter Beutner wrote: Don't get me wrong I still think it is perfectly valid that wine is doing that sort of hack to get existing windows applications working but you really shouldn't advertise it as a solution to platform independence and e

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Peter Beutner
Dmitry Timoshkov schrieb: "Peter Beutner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Why? Wine is effectively just a different toolkit, like QT or GTK (albeit much larger) that give applications a Windows, KDE and Gnome look respectively. Take Notepad for example - with some slight modifications you could eve

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Tony Lambregts
Jeremy White wrote: >>Not that I mean to sound like a pessimist, but I'm really just calling >>it as I see it. No offense to anyone intended. :) > > > This, in a nutshell, is Wine's greatest challenge > (stepping even outside ISV boundaries for a minute). > > I believe, either because I'm insane (t

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Michael Jung
On Friday 16 December 2005 15:41, Peter Beutner wrote: > The point is that it won't be integrated in neither kernel or glibc. Integration in the loader is just one possibility. Wine needs to load code at fixed positions. Thus, there has to be a possibility to do it. Currently we do it in a way

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Marcus Meissner
> The point is that it won't be integrated in neither kernel or glibc. At > least I can't imagine that this will happen. Why should anybody integrate > another binary loader/memory layout into the kernel/libc where there is > already a fully working one? > Just because some people don't want to

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Peter Beutner
Michael Jung schrieb: On Friday 16 December 2005 12:54, Peter Beutner wrote: Let's just look at the problem with the memory layout. Wine relies on the possibility to load certain codes at fixed addresses as this is how it works under windows. Linux choose exact the opposite direction, i.e. try

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Dmitry Timoshkov
"Peter Beutner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Why? Wine is effectively just a different toolkit, like QT or GTK (albeit much larger) that give applications a Windows, KDE and Gnome look respectively. Take Notepad for example - with some slight modifications you could even modify the File Open dia

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread David Gümbel
On Freitag 16 Dezember 2005 10:49, Peter Beutner wrote: > Robert Shearman schrieb: > > Peter Beutner wrote: > >> Maybe it's just me but when reading all this I got the feeling that > >> writing windows applications(which work with wine) is just *the* way > >> to go. > > > > It is the cheapest way

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Michael Jung
On Friday 16 December 2005 12:54, Peter Beutner wrote: > Let's just look at the problem with the memory layout. Wine relies on the > possibility to load certain codes at fixed addresses as this is how it > works under windows. Linux choose exact the opposite direction, i.e. try to > ensure that lib

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Peter Beutner
James Liggett schrieb: I really fear that this will end up with vendors loudly advertising linux support and proudly putting linux stickers on their products where everything you find inside are just the same windows .exe files and a readme stating that these will work fine with wine. Which at

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Peter Beutner
Michael Jung schrieb: On Friday 16 December 2005 10:49, Peter Beutner wrote: Wine is _not_ just a different toolkit. Just look at all the "nasty" stuff wine has to do to emulate the windows process environment. I guess in the long term a project like wine, if successfull, doesn't have to l

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Markus G�mmel
Hi, > I'll vote against a wine-isv list. History has shown we're not > responsible enough to have many mailing lists. Sure, if it takes > off.. great. But more than likely we'll be having a discussion on > wine-devel in 18 months about getting rid of the list because only a > handful of people

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Michael Jung
On Friday 16 December 2005 10:49, Peter Beutner wrote: > Wine is _not_ just a different toolkit. Just look at all the "nasty" stuff > wine has to do to emulate the windows process environment. I guess in the long term a project like wine, if successfull, doesn't have to live with the restriction

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Peter Beutner
Robert Shearman schrieb: Peter Beutner wrote: IMHO all this stuff goes a bit too much into the wrong direction. I really fear that this will end up with vendors loudly advertising linux support and proudly putting linux stickers on their products where everything you find inside are just the

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-16 Thread Jeremy White
> Not that I mean to sound like a pessimist, but I'm really just calling > it as I see it. No offense to anyone intended. :) This, in a nutshell, is Wine's greatest challenge (stepping even outside ISV boundaries for a minute). I believe, either because I'm insane (the likely explanation), or bec

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Robert Shearman
Peter Beutner wrote: IMHO all this stuff goes a bit too much into the wrong direction. I really fear that this will end up with vendors loudly advertising linux support and proudly putting linux stickers on their products where everything you find inside are just the same windows .exe files

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Dan Kegel
On 12/15/05, Peter Beutner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > it's definitly a good thing when vendors care about their product running > with wine or > companies migrating to linux trying to get their highly-specialized-app to > work with wine. > But imho it _shouldn't_ be the long term solution. We'

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread James Liggett
> I really fear that this will end up with vendors loudly advertising linux > support and > proudly putting linux stickers on their products where everything you find > inside are just > the same windows .exe files and a readme stating that these will work fine > with wine. > Which at least i

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Peter Beutner
Scott Ritchie schrieb: On Tue, 2005-12-13 at 22:33 -0800, Dan Kegel wrote: I used to hate the term ISV (Independent Software Vendor) since it sounded so acronymy compared to 'developer', but it's very commonly used in the industry to refer to outfits which are trying to write and sell off-the-s

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Dan Kegel
On 12/15/05, Brian Vincent <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > You're secretly just trying to get me to finish the commercial page I > promised, huh? :-) > I'll vote against a wine-isv list. History has shown we're not > responsible enough to have many mailing lists. Sure, if it takes > off.. great.

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Brian Vincent
You're secretly just trying to get me to finish the commercial page I promised, huh? I'll vote against a wine-isv list. History has shown we're not responsible enough to have many mailing lists. Sure, if it takes off.. great. But more than likely we'll be having a discussion on wine-devel in 18

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread David Gümbel
On Mittwoch 14 Dezember 2005 07:33, Dan Kegel wrote: > How about we create a new mailing list, wine-isv, aimed squarely > at ISVs and the Wine community members who want to > help them? Sounds like a good idea to me ;) David pgpntIJmD7w1g.pgp Description: PGP signature

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Stefan Dösinger
Hi, > How about we create a new mailing list, wine-isv, aimed squarely > at ISVs and the Wine community members who want to > help them? I'd say go for it! Stefan pgp3gHbP0Ls0o.pgp Description: PGP signature

Re: Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-15 Thread Scott Ritchie
On Tue, 2005-12-13 at 22:33 -0800, Dan Kegel wrote: > I used to hate the term ISV (Independent Software Vendor) since > it sounded so acronymy compared to 'developer', but it's > very commonly used in the industry to refer to outfits which > are trying to write and sell off-the-shelf software -- an

Create new mailing list wine-isv?

2005-12-13 Thread Dan Kegel
I used to hate the term ISV (Independent Software Vendor) since it sounded so acronymy compared to 'developer', but it's very commonly used in the industry to refer to outfits which are trying to write and sell off-the-shelf software -- and as monkey-boy said, Microsoft is where it is partly becaus