Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread H. Verbeet
On 12/04/07, Tom Wickline [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Those guys ran 5 game test and Wine's performance is clearly superior to that of Cedega on benchmarks where Wine was run, they give no details of the Wine configuration, So I can only presume it's a default setup. And since there *trying* to

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Stefan Dösinger
Tbh, I don't think an OpenGL performance comparison is particularly interesting in the first place. Though the interesting thing is that I did my own native Linux vs native MacOS vs Wine benchmarks with glExcess a few days ago. I got pretty much the opposite result. Granted, my benchmarking

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Tom Wickline
On 4/12/07, Stefan Dösinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But I agree with Henri that a Direct3D performance comparison will be much more interesting. Well were all three in agreement, I believe a well rounded benchmark review is in order ;) Some test software: Disk I/O Memory: Performance Mark

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Mirek
Tom Wickline napsal(a): On 4/12/07, Stefan Dösinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But I agree with Henri that a Direct3D performance comparison will be much more interesting. Well were all three in agreement, I believe a well rounded benchmark review is in order ;) Some test software: Disk

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Stefan Dösinger
Am Donnerstag 12 April 2007 16:22 schrieb Tom Wickline: On 4/12/07, Stefan Dösinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But I agree with Henri that a Direct3D performance comparison will be much more interesting. Well were all three in agreement, I believe a well rounded benchmark review is in order

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Stefan Dösinger
Nvidia SDK D3D Demos? Nvidia SDK OpenGL Demos? I don't think SDK demos are good performance benchmarks for overall performance. They can find bottlenecks, but not predict how good something is for games. They could show which features work in Wine / Cedega, but I think that would be unfair

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Tom Wickline
On 4/12/07, Stefan Dösinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Nvidia SDK D3D Demos? Nvidia SDK OpenGL Demos? I don't think SDK demos are good performance benchmarks for overall performance. They can find bottlenecks, but not predict how good something is for games. They could show which features work

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Tom Wickline
On 4/12/07, Stefan Dösinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I guess some hl2 timedemos may be good too Was this what you had in mind? : http://www.hocbench.com/hl2.html -- Tom Wickline Respectable computing - Linux/FOSS

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Tom Wickline
On 4/12/07, Tom Wickline [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Performance Mark 5.0 Lets kick in 6.1 as well. http://wiki.winehq.org/BenchMark-0.9.6?action=AttachFiledo=gettarget=PerformanceTest6.1.png -- Tom Wickline Respectable computing - Linux/FOSS

Re: Wine vs. Cedega in Benchmarks

2007-04-12 Thread Stefan Dösinger
Am Donnerstag 12 April 2007 16:57 schrieb Tom Wickline: On 4/12/07, Stefan Dösinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Nvidia SDK D3D Demos? Nvidia SDK OpenGL Demos? I don't think SDK demos are good performance benchmarks for overall performance. They can find bottlenecks, but not predict how