[Zen] Re: understanding zen

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
Merle, You and Edgar are like two peas in a pod...always assuming people think something they probably don't and certainly didn't say. Who on this group said you were a zen teacher? Only Edgar and you as far as I can remember. Who on this group implied they did not believe you were a zen teac

[Zen] Re: quickie

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
Good Luck! Whatever it is I hope they find it and FIX IT! ...and keep us posted...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester wrote: > > > > > > > bare with me group... > > .went to doc... something a miss with lung.. > .needed blood test today and ct. scan 2 morrow  10:00am...

Re: [Zen] Re: understanding zen

2012-11-13 Thread Merle Lester
 bill..i shop with my eyes wide open, my ears pricked and alert.. you'd be surprised at the amazing conversations i have had with total strangers who suddenly for no reason eagerly tell me their life stories..and i point them to zen!  i am a teacher after all which all of you in the group den

[Zen] quickie

2012-11-13 Thread Merle Lester
bare with me group... .went to doc... something a miss with lung.. .needed blood test today and ct. scan 2 morrow  10:00am...  he is thinking worst case: blood clot in lung..deep breath for me it hurts Merle www.wix.com/merlewiitpom/1

[Zen] Siddhartha died long time back but no one noticed it’

2012-11-13 Thread SURESH JAGADEESAN
Dear All, For last 4 days I was in leave for Deepavali, hence I could not read most of your mails. But I used to see in my mobile and scroll down messages, but not read to its full meaning. I see Mr.Phantom continues with his denial of the existence of the god. The problem here is language and i

[Zen] Re: understanding zen

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
Merle, When I go to the shopping mall I shop. What do you do? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester wrote: > > edgar. > > .i can understand what you are saying...and that is how i see it except i > cannot explain it like you have.. > > .zen to me is being in the moment ale

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
I agree with Chris. I think face-to-face interaction with your teacher is essential - especially prior to realizing Buddha Nature (kensho). But then again that's the way I did it so maybe I'm just being too narrowly focused on that. I just know even the presence of others in the sangha while

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
Siska, I'm sure some zen centers are a little different than others, but the in the main sangha I attended when I began my training there were two teachers, one head monk and several senior monks. They all acted as teachers or at least guides. Students did have a 1-to-1 student-teacher relati

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Chris, Could be a way of softening a person up, for an eventual participation at a real zen center. On the other hand, it could be JUST what folks NEED who CANNOT ever get to a real zen center. I think the Roshis involved will see to all that's needed to teach people as well as possible, give

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Mike, Wouldn't be Zen without it (selling water by the river, that is). BTW, the river in Tucson is DRY (water-table has descended 950 feet). --Joe PS As far as the Cash goes, "...Never leave home without it". ;-) (to re-appropriate a line used by the American Express Corp., which would not i

Re: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread mike brown
Joe, Tut tut! You both charging for selling water by the river again?.. From: Joe To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Sent: Tuesday, 13 November 2012, 22:13 Subject: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...   Mike, It was Bill!(!). I can't take credit (only

[Zen] Re: understanding zen

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Merle, Choose any way of sitting with the spine straight. Eyes always OPEN in zazen. Incense may burn in the room, and it has an exact purpose. We do not "listen for gongs", but bells are used to send signals so that the voice need never be used. I know you are clearly quoting someone else,

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Mike, It was Bill!(!). I can't take credit (only Cash, pls.). --Joe > mike brown wrote: > > I really can't imagine anyone following the Zen path and not having a teacher > for exactly the reason Joe gave about a practitioner potentially believing > (falsely) they've experienced Buddha Nature

Re: [Zen] understanding zen

2012-11-13 Thread mike brown
Merle, >.practising zen to me is not sitting cross legged on "handwoven mats,  eyes shut tight, sniffing incense and  listening to gongs." You're certainly correct about that, but neither is it about sitting in a university lecture theatre/library studying advanced psychology or neuroscience.

[Zen] Funny T Shirts | Offensive, Funny, Hilarious, Novelty, Humorous TShirts - Bad Idea T Shirts

2012-11-13 Thread Merle Lester
anything zen here..merle http://www.badideatshirts.com/?gclid=CNbsmvLAyrMCFaRLpgodVTUANA

[Zen] George Carlin - Video "I Don't Vote"

2012-11-13 Thread Merle Lester
light entertainment... merle > >Subject: George Carlin - Video "I Don't Vote" > > > >http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article32953.htm > > > > > > > >

[Zen] Re: Wish you all a very Happy Deepavali

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Suresh, et al. (All), I suppose the lengthy Deepawvali celebration lasts until today, and culminates today, on New Moon day. I forget to mention the dancing, earlier! So, when the total eclipse of the Sun occurs across the NE coast and Great Barrier Reef of Australia today, that will be ident

[Zen] understanding zen

2012-11-13 Thread Merle Lester
edgar. .i can understand what you are saying...and that is how i see it except i cannot explain it like you have.. .zen to me is being in the moment alert and forever present...as i see it we zen through the day.. .practising zen to me is not sitting cross legged on "handwoven mats,  eyes shu

[Zen] Re: Wish you all a very Happy Deepavali

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Suresh, I hope Deepavali was good for you this year. I remember it very fondly when I lived in New York City. I had some close Indian friends, but there was also a big festival held in Central Park, and of course lots of very good food, there, and THOUSANDS of people. Hundreds of people fle

Re: [Zen] Re: Is buddha nature coninuous?

2012-11-13 Thread mike brown
Edgar, It's good to see you back and well. Unfortunately I can't say the same about your theories. "It's an updated understanding of how mind works that was unknown when the Zen texts were written."  Are you saying that prior to this 'breakthru' in neuroscience the Patriarchs weren't prac

Re: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread mike brown
It's an interesting difference this thing about teachers in Zen and vipassana. I really can't imagine anyone following the Zen path and not having a teacher for exactly the reason Joe gave about a practitioner potentially believing (falsely) they've experienced Buddha Nature. I think there's muc

[Zen] Re: who's sniping now?..

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Edgar, Reality, yes. Do you know how philosophically unsophisticated that sounds? You'll say that's good, because you do not want to emulate the Sophists (who tried to teach Virtue, for money). But you remind me of the undergraduates I taught in intro- Philosophy courses, when they didn't y

Re: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
http://www.treeleaf.org/about-treeleaf-teachers-jundo-taigu-and-our-lineage/ I am highly sceptical but again without much actual experience of it -- as a Soto student and as a parent I put a lot of stock in face to face transmission. --Chris Thanks, --Chris ch...@austin-lane.net +1-301-270-6524

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Chris, Interesting! An online zendo. Maybe I need to get out *less*, then. ;-) --Joe > ChrisAustinLane wrote: > > There is an electronic Zendo that is completely online. They broadcast the > bell ringer on the Internet and all sit together at the same time but not in > the same place. >

Re: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread ChrisAustinLane
There is an electronic Zendo that is completely online. They broadcast the bell ringer on the Internet and all sit together at the same time but not in the same place. It seems quite different from the eyeball to eyeball teaching that I know but I also speak from the outside, so to speak. Th

Re: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread siska_cen
Hi Bill, I supposed teacher-student relationship is something that is highly valued in zen tradition. Lineage is maintained and there are initiation and stuffs. When Teacher gives advice, these are taken with sort of authority. I'm not saying that in vipassana there is no teacher. My teacher ha

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Siska, Yes, sitting and everything else. There are some 8 or ten formal practices that I could mention immediately if you asked, and some others that I'd come up with after about a minute or two of head-scratching. But if you add other things in, too, like brushing one's teeth, the practices

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Joe
Bill!, It's just a book of words by some favorite teachers and friends. Sometimes I get lonely for their company. This book contains something of their teaching, their delivery, their very voice, their wisdom, and kindness. They could as well be talking about Baseball, and I'd still like thei

Re: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread siska_cen
Joe, When you said practice, what do you mean? Sittings or anything else? Siska -Original Message- From: "Joe" Sender: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Date: Mon, 12 Nov 2012 17:22:09 To: Reply-To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Subject: [Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated... Siska, I think

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
Siska, I didn't mean you HAVE to have a teacher to realize Buddha Nature. What I meant was if you wanted to work on the koan Mu you should do that with a teacher. I actually do recommend a teacher. I don't know how anyone could realize Buddha Nature without one. I know it's certainly possib

[Zen] Re: Mu - Graphically Illustrated...

2012-11-13 Thread Bill!
Joe, I looked at the synopsis of that book, but even before I did I was sure it was not a book on 'Mu'. There is really nothing to write about. It's a book on Buddha Nature - I guess. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, "Joe" wrote: > > Bill!, > > I opine it's too much of a good t