Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS QoS and priorities

2012-12-06 Thread Matt Van Mater
> > > > I'm unclear on the best way to warm data... do you mean to simply `dd > if=/volumes/myvol/data of=/dev/null`? I have always been under the > impression that ARC/L2ARC has rate limiting how much data can be added to > the cache per interval (i can't remember the interval). Is this not the

Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS QoS and priorities

2012-12-06 Thread Matt Van Mater
> > > At present, I do not see async write QoS as being interesting. That leaves > sync writes and reads > as the managed I/O. Unfortunately, with HDDs, the variance in response > time >> queue management > time, so the results are less useful than the case with SSDs. Control > theory works, once a

Re: [zfs-discuss] ZFS QoS and priorities

2012-12-05 Thread Matt Van Mater
I don't have anything significant to add to this conversation, but wanted to chime in that I also find the concept of a QOS-like capability very appealing and that Jim's recent emails resonate with me. You're not alone! I believe there are many use cases where a granular prioritization that contr

Re: [zfs-discuss] Different size / manufacturer L2ARC

2012-09-26 Thread Matt Van Mater
Excellent thanks to you both. I knew of both those methods and wanted to make sure i wasn't missing something! On Wed, Sep 26, 2012 at 11:21 AM, Dan Swartzendruber wrote: > ** > On 9/26/2012 11:18 AM, Matt Van Mater wrote: > > If the added device is slower, you will experience

Re: [zfs-discuss] Different size / manufacturer L2ARC

2012-09-26 Thread Matt Van Mater
> > If the added device is slower, you will experience a slight drop in > per-op performance, however, if your working set needs another SSD, > overall it might improve your throughput (as the cache hit ratio will > increase). > Thanks for your fast reply! I think I know the answer to this questi

[zfs-discuss] Different size / manufacturer L2ARC

2012-09-26 Thread Matt Van Mater
I've looked on the mailing list (the evil tuning wikis are down) and haven't seen a reference to this seemingly simple question... I have two OCZ Vertex 4 SSDs acting as L2ARC. I have a spare Crucial SSD (about 1.5 years old) that isn't getting much use and i'm curious about adding it to the pool