Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-23 Thread R.G. Keen
Most ECC setups are as you describe. The memory hardware detects and corrects all 1-bit errors, and detects all two-bit errors on its own. What ... should ... happen is that the OS should get an interrupt when this happens so it has the opportunity to note the error in logs and to higher level s

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-23 Thread R.G. Keen
Most ECC setups are as you describe. The memory hardware detects and corrects all 1-bit errors, and detects all two-bit errors on its own. What ... should ... happen is that the OS should get an interrupt when this happens so it has the opportunity to note the error in logs and to higher level s

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-23 Thread Richard Elling
On Nov 23, 2009, at 12:48 PM, Miles Nordin wrote: "tc" == Tim Cook writes: tc> I believe that opensolaris can do the ECC scrubbing in tc> software even of the motherboard BIOS doesn't support it. yeah, I don't really understand how the solaris idle page scrubbing interacts with whatev

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-23 Thread Miles Nordin
> "tc" == Tim Cook writes: tc> I believe that opensolaris can do the ECC scrubbing in tc> software even of the motherboard BIOS doesn't support it. yeah, I don't really understand how the solaris idle page scrubbing interacts with whatever. scrubbing's a hardware feature for AMD. I

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-23 Thread Al Hopper
On Sun, Nov 22, 2009 at 12:49 PM, Tim Cook wrote: > snip > Someone can correct me if I'm wrong... but I believe that opensolaris can do > the ECC scrubbing in software even of the motherboard BIOS doesn't support > it. The OS is not involved with the ECC functionality of the hardware AF

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-22 Thread R.G. Keen
> Someone can correct me if I'm wrong... but I believe > that opensolaris can do the ECC scrubbing in software > even of the motherboard BIOS doesn't support > it. That's interesting - I didn't run into that in the background search. I suspect that some motherboards just accept the ECC memory bit

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-22 Thread Tim Cook
On Sun, Nov 22, 2009 at 12:43 PM, R.G. Keen wrote: > Thanks for replying! I did look into that. The AMD design was my second > choice. > > It was : > AMD Athlon II X2 240e (to get low power; the dual core and lack of L3 help > there) > ASUS motherboard (see considerations below) > Cheap VGA? LAN

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-22 Thread R.G. Keen
Thanks for replying! I did look into that. The AMD design was my second choice. It was : AMD Athlon II X2 240e (to get low power; the dual core and lack of L3 help there) ASUS motherboard (see considerations below) Cheap VGA? LAN card? This is the mire that ultimately bogged down this one. Give

Re: [zfs-discuss] The 100, 000th beginner question about a zfs server

2009-11-22 Thread Orvar Korvar
I would suggest a CPU with small L2 cache, as L2 cache will not help a file server. This allows you use AMD's new 45W cpu. And 64 bit. 2-4 cores. And use raidz2. -- This message posted from opensolaris.org ___ zfs-discuss mailing list zfs-discuss@opens