Re: [zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-23 Thread Jeff Bacon
Have I missed any changes/updates in the situation? I'm been getting very bad performance out of a LSI 9211-4i card (mpt_sas) with Seagate Constellation 2TB SAS disks, SM SC846E1 and Intel X-25E/M SSDs. Long story short, I/O will hang for over 1 minute at random under heavy load. Hm. That

Re: [zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-23 Thread Giovanni Tirloni
On Wed, Jun 23, 2010 at 10:14 AM, Jeff Bacon ba...@walleyesoftware.com wrote: Have I missed any changes/updates in the situation? I'm been getting very bad performance out of a LSI 9211-4i card (mpt_sas) with Seagate Constellation 2TB SAS disks, SM SC846E1 and Intel X-25E/M SSDs. Long story

Re: [zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-23 Thread Jeff Bacon
Gack, that's the same message we're seeing with the mpt controller with SATA drives. I've never seen it with a SAS drive before . Has anyone noticed a trend of 2TB SATA drives en-masse not working well with the LSI SASx28/x36 expander chips? I can seemingly reproduce it on demand - hook 4 2TB

Re: [zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-23 Thread Jeff Bacon
I'm using iozone to get some performance numbers and I/O hangs when it's doing the writing phase. This pool has: 18 x 2TB SAS disks as 9 data mirrors 2 x 32GB X-25E as log mirror 1 x 160GB X-160M as cache iostat shows 2 I/O operations active and SSDs at 100% busy when it's stuck.

Re: [zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-23 Thread Giovanni Tirloni
On Wed, Jun 23, 2010 at 2:43 PM, Jeff Bacon ba...@walleyesoftware.com wrote: Swapping the 9211-4i for a MegaRAID ELP (mega_sas) improves performance by 30-40% instantly and there are no hangs anymore so I'm guessing it's something related to the mpt_sas driver. Wait. The mpt_sas

Re: [zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-22 Thread Giovanni Tirloni
On Fri, Jun 18, 2010 at 9:53 AM, Jeff Bacon ba...@twinight.org wrote: I know that this has been well-discussed already, but it's been a few months - WD caviars with mpt/mpt_sas generating lots of retryable read errors, spitting out lots of beloved Log info 3108 received for target

[zfs-discuss] WD caviar/mpt issues

2010-06-18 Thread Jeff Bacon
I know that this has been well-discussed already, but it's been a few months - WD caviars with mpt/mpt_sas generating lots of retryable read errors, spitting out lots of beloved Log info 3108 received for target messages, and just generally not working right. (SM 836EL1 and 836TQ chassis