Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Dick Davies
On 04/10/2007, Nathan Kroenert [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Client A - import pool make couple-o-changes Client B - import pool -f (heh) Oct 4 15:03:12 fozzie ^Mpanic[cpu0]/thread=ff0002b51c80: Oct 4 15:03:12 fozzie genunix: [ID 603766 kern.notice] assertion failed: dmu_read(os,

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Ben Rockwood
Dick Davies wrote: On 04/10/2007, Nathan Kroenert [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Client A - import pool make couple-o-changes Client B - import pool -f (heh) Oct 4 15:03:12 fozzie ^Mpanic[cpu0]/thread=ff0002b51c80: Oct 4 15:03:12 fozzie genunix: [ID 603766 kern.notice]

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Victor Engle
Wouldn't this be the known feature where a write error to zfs forces a panic? Vic On 10/4/07, Ben Rockwood [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dick Davies wrote: On 04/10/2007, Nathan Kroenert [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Client A - import pool make couple-o-changes Client B - import

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Nathan Kroenert
I think it's a little more sinister than that... I'm only just trying to import the pool. Not even yet doing any I/O to it... Perhaps it's the same cause, I don't know... But I'm certainly not convinced that I'd be happy with a 25K, for example, panicing just because I tried to import a dud

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Victor Engle
Perhaps it's the same cause, I don't know... But I'm certainly not convinced that I'd be happy with a 25K, for example, panicing just because I tried to import a dud pool... I'm ok(ish) with the panic on a failed write to a non-redundant storage. I expect it by now... I agree, forcing a

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread eric kustarz
Client A - import pool make couple-o-changes Client B - import pool -f (heh) Client A + B - With both mounting the same pool, touched a couple of files, and removed a couple of files from each client Client A + B - zpool export Client A - Attempted import and dropped the panic.

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread A Darren Dunham
On Thu, Oct 04, 2007 at 08:36:10AM -0600, eric kustarz wrote: Client A - import pool make couple-o-changes Client B - import pool -f (heh) Client A + B - With both mounting the same pool, touched a couple of files, and removed a couple of files from each client Client A +

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Nathan Kroenert
Erik - Thanks for that, but I know the pool is corrupted - That was kind if the point of the exercise. The bug (at least to me) is ZFS panicing Solaris just trying to import the dud pool. But, maybe I'm missing your point? Nathan. eric kustarz wrote: Client A - import pool make

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Eric Schrock
On Fri, Oct 05, 2007 at 08:20:13AM +1000, Nathan Kroenert wrote: Erik - Thanks for that, but I know the pool is corrupted - That was kind if the point of the exercise. The bug (at least to me) is ZFS panicing Solaris just trying to import the dud pool. But, maybe I'm missing your

Re: [zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-04 Thread Nathan Kroenert
Awesome. Thanks, Eric. :) This type of feature / fix is quite important to a number of the guys in the our local OSUG. In particular, they are adamant that they cannot use ZFS in production until it stops panicing the whole box for isolated filesystem / zpool failures. This will be a big

[zfs-discuss] When I stab myself with this knife, it hurts... But - should it kill me?

2007-10-03 Thread Nathan Kroenert
Some people are just dumb. Take me, for instance... :) Was just looking into ZFS on iscsi and doing some painful and unnatural things to my boxes and dropped a panic I was not expecting. Here is what I did. Server: (S10_u4 sparc) - zpool create usb /dev/dsk/c4t0d0s0 (on a 4gb USB stick,