Re: [zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-21 Thread Wes Felter
On 6/19/10 3:56 AM, Arne Jansen wrote: while thinking about using the OCZ Vertex 2 Pro SSD (which according to spec page has supercaps built in) as a shared slog and L2ARC device IMO it might be better to use the smallest (50GB, maybe overprovisioned down to ~20GB) Vertex 2 Pro as slog and a

Re: [zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-21 Thread Arne Jansen
Wes Felter wrote: On 6/19/10 3:56 AM, Arne Jansen wrote: while thinking about using the OCZ Vertex 2 Pro SSD (which according to spec page has supercaps built in) as a shared slog and L2ARC device IMO it might be better to use the smallest (50GB, maybe overprovisioned down to ~20GB) Vertex 2

Re: [zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-20 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Sat, 19 Jun 2010, Richard Jahnel wrote: For a certain brand of indellix drive I calculated the life span in the following way. Based on the maximum sustained write speed of the drive and the size of the drive (256GB by the way) it would take 9 months to over write the entire drive 1

Re: [zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-20 Thread Richard Jahnel
TBH write amp was not considered, but since I've never heard of a write amp over 1.5, for my purposes on the 256gb drives they still last welll over the required 5 year life span. Again it does hurt a lot when your using smaller drives that less space available for wear leveling. I suppose

[zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-19 Thread Arne Jansen
Hi, I don't know if it's already been discussed here, but while thinking about using the OCZ Vertex 2 Pro SSD (which according to spec page has supercaps built in) as a shared slog and L2ARC device it stroke me that this might not be a such a good idea. Because this SSD is MLC based, write

Re: [zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-19 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Sat, 19 Jun 2010, Arne Jansen wrote: If the ZIL is heavily used, the same 10% of the device get written over and over again, reducing the life span by 90%. The SSD design might implement wear leveling which moves an old block which was only written once or twice to the block with heavy

Re: [zfs-discuss] does sharing an SSD as slog and l2arc reduces its life span?

2010-06-19 Thread Richard Jahnel
Well pretty much by definition any writes shorten the drives life, the more writes the shorter it is. That said, here is some interesting math that I did before I built my first mlc array. For a certain brand of indellix drive I calculated the life span in the following way. Based on the