[ZION] True Christians

2002-11-28 Thread John W. Redelfs
There are two kinds of Christianity in the world: True Christianity and false Christianity. True Christianity is found only in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. --JWR // /// ZION LIST CHARTER: Please r

[ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread Gary Smith
I recall Joseph Smith having a vision (could it be in DC 137?), where he sees his non-baptized brother Alvin in the Celestial Kingdom. Alvin is obviously considered a 'true Christian' even though he has not yet been baptized. I would imagine that this largesse by Christ would be given to others, s

[ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread Gary Smith
I guess the meaning of a true Christian depends on one's definition. Does true Christian mean one who understands and accepts and acts righteously on all the things Christ teaches to the smallest minutiae? If so, then NONE of us are true Christians, even in the LDS Church, except Jesus himself. If

[ZION] True Christians

2002-12-04 Thread Gary Smith
So, until you get your eating habit under control, you aren't following the D&C, and this means you aren't a true Christian because you aren't following the prophets? I definitely wouldn't be considered one under your definition, either, since there are many things I struggle with and do not follow

[ZION] True Christians

2002-12-04 Thread Gary Smith
You are thinking of the short mortal term we live in. All will bow the knee and profess Christ as Lord. The majority of them will eventually accept Christ, and though they may not merit the Celestial Kingdom, they still will accept the gospel someday. It is just that they will not have the ability

[ZION] True Christians

2002-12-04 Thread Gary Smith
Regardless, in 1836 when the revelation was given, Alvin still had not been baptized, but was considered by God good enough to be in a vision of the Celestial Kingdom. This tells me that the man was accepted as a 'true' Christian. K'aya K'ama, Gerald/gary Smithgszion1 @juno.comhttp://www

[ZION] True Christians

2002-12-08 Thread Gary Smith
No, it isn't a straw man. It is exactly my point. Just where does a mortal being draw the line between what is a 'true' Christian and what isn't? Your definition keeps shifting on me. You said it was someone who fully followed Christ and his living prophets. Yet, King Benjamin told us that none of

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-11-29 Thread Paul Osborne
>There are two kinds of Christianity in the world: True Christianity and >false Christianity. True Christianity is found only in the Church of Jesus >Christ of Latter-day Saints. --JWR That's exactly right, John. If any Latter-day Saint were to join up with any of those false Christian churc

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-11-29 Thread Jon Spencer
Unfortunately, however, many members of the Church are not true Christians, and many members of other Churches are (which, of course, is not unfortunate - the only unfortunate thing is that they are not in the true Church). Jon John W. Redelfs wrote: > There are two kinds of Christianity in the w

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-11-29 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Jon Spencer favored us with: Unfortunately, however, many members of the Church are not true Christians, and many members of other Churches are (which, of course, is not unfortunate - the only unfortunate thing is that they are not in the true Church). I agree that many mem

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-11-30 Thread Paul Osborne
I agree with JWR in so much as a true Christian must be a baptized member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and have a testimony given by the Holy Ghost. Paul O [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sign Up for Juno Platinum Internet A

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-11-30 Thread Jon Spencer
If someone (a) takes on the name of Christ, and (b) keeps His commandments which he has given them, then that person IMVHO is a true Christian. They may not have as many commandments given to them as we have, but then again the Nephites didn't have all the commandments given to them that we have h

RE: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-01 Thread Chet
John, our BLT said (but without so many sideways carrots as appear in this reply - but that's because I can't get Zion to appear in my e-mail box and have to use this clunky reply system on Topica. Rant, rave. Oh - where was I?): > > I agree that many members of the Church are not true Christ

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-01 Thread Jon Spencer
have them read and explain the hundreds of segments that say they are wrong. but that, of course, is the NM in me. Jon - Original Message - From: "Chet" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Sunday, December 01, 2002 11:45 AM Subject: RE: [ZION] True C

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-01 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Jon Spencer favored us with: If someone (a) takes on the name of Christ, and (b) keeps His commandments which he has given them, then that person IMVHO is a true Christian. The first thing a person must do to qualify as a true Christian is to believe in him. Then he must

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-01 Thread Marc A. Schindler
I think what John's trying to say, if I may be so presumptuous, is that the principle is clear. It is the judgement at the individual level that we are cautioned about. I believe my grandmother, who passed away in April at 96 to have been one of the most Christian people I ever knew, yet she never

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-01 Thread Stacy Smith
To add to this perspective, how many people who claim to be true Christians: 1. Visit the sick. 2. Visit people in prison. 3. When they have a feast they invite the halt, lame and the blind. Stacy. At 05:56 AM 12/02/2002 -0900, you wrote: After much pondering, Jon Spencer favored us with:

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-01 Thread Stacy Smith
If we only go by that definition, then those living up to the only light they know and following Christ all the way to the best of their ability cannot be considered Christians. I think I'd have a problem with that. Can they go to the celestial kingdom? Maybe, in some cases. Can they progre

RE: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread Chet
Stacy Smith wrote: > To add to this perspective, how many people who claim to be true > Christians: > > 1. Visit the sick. Regularly. Of course, some of them weren't sick before I arrived. > 2. Visit people in prison. I visit people in political office and members of the Southern Baptist

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread Val
-- Stacy Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: From: Stacy Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [ZION] True Christians Date: Sun, 01 Dec 2002 21:48:15 -0800 If we only go by that definition, then those living up to the only light they know and followin

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread Mark Gregson
> I recall Joseph Smith having a vision (could it be in DC 137?), where he > sees his non-baptized brother Alvin in the Celestial Kingdom. Alvin is > obviously considered a 'true Christian' even though he has not yet been > baptized. Joseph Smith had the vision in 1836 in the Kirtland temple.

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Stacy Smith favored us with: If we only go by that definition, then those living up to the only light they know and following Christ all the way to the best of their ability cannot be considered Christians. I think I'd have a problem with that. Can they go to the celesti

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Stacy Smith favored us with: To add to this perspective, how many people who claim to be true Christians: 1. Visit the sick. 2. Visit people in prison. 3. When they have a feast they invite the halt, lame and the blind. I have met many saints who do these things. --JWR

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: Maybe someday I can become a true Christian in John's definition. Until then, I'm glad that Christ accepts me with all the shades of gray and excess baggage I carry with me. You are already a true Christian by my definition. You follow Christ, o

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: If it means those who are considered at least honorable by God (DC 76), then all heading toward the Terrestrial and Celestial are true Christians. These are, in fact described as 'children of Christ' in a few areas of the scriptures. Even if they

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: So, before any of us less than perfect people try to proclaim such a strong statement as some have given, how about defining just which one of these definitions you are using. Otherwise, you are painting with a very broad brush against those who Ch

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: I recall Joseph Smith having a vision (could it be in DC 137?), where he sees his non-baptized brother Alvin in the Celestial Kingdom. Alvin is obviously considered a 'true Christian' even though he has not yet been baptized. Alvin was was most c

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-02 Thread Marc A. Schindler
I honestly don't know. I believe baptism is required -- this is what we are taught. But I don't claim to know all of God's ways, just that He is just and He is merciful. Whatever that might end up meaning. I'm also reminded not to be too judgemental by the parable of the labourers who were hired a

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-03 Thread Jon Spencer
Some of my best friends do these things! Jon John W. Redelfs wrote: > After much pondering, Stacy Smith favored us with: > >To add to this perspective, how many people who claim to be true Christians: > > > >1. Visit the sick. > >2. Visit people in prison. > >3. When they have a feast they in

RE: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Chet
Gary Smith wrote: > So, until you get your eating habit under control, you aren't following > the D&C, and this means you aren't a true Christian because you aren't > following the prophets? I definitely wouldn't be considered one under > your definition, either, since there are many things I stru

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: So, until you get your eating habit under control, you aren't following the D&C, and this means you aren't a true Christian because you aren't following the prophets? I definitely wouldn't be considered one under your definition, either, since ther

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Mark Gregson
> Regardless, in 1836 when the revelation was given, Alvin still had not > been baptized, but was considered by God good enough to be in a vision of > the Celestial Kingdom. This tells me that the man was accepted as a > 'true' Christian. I have no idea what God condsiders a true Christian (o

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread John W. Redelfs
--- Gary Smith --- Regardless, in 1836 when the revelation was given, Alvin still had not been baptized, but was considered by God good enough to be in a vision of the Celestial Kingdom. This tells me that the man was accepted as a 'true' Christian. --- Mark Gregson --- Joseph Smith had the visio

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Elmer L. Fairbank
At 08:37 12/5/2002 -0900, BLT scares us all: --- Mark Gregson --- Joseph Smith had the vision in 1836 in the Kirtland temple. In the vision he saw his father, mother and Alvin in the celestial kingdom. However, his father and mother were still alive when Joseph Smith had the vision. Therefore,

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Mark Gregson favored us with: What do we know about being a true Christian? Not much, really, because God has never revealed any definition for "true Christian". He has given the requirements for entering the Celestial Kingdom, however, and if you want that to be your de

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Paul Osborne
"There can be no real and true Christianity, even with good works, unless we are deeply and personally committed to the reality of Jesus Christ as the Only Begotten Son of the Father, who bought us, who purchased us in the great act of atonement." Spencer W. Kimball, “The Savior—The Center of Our

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: You are thinking of the short mortal term we live in. All will bow the knee and profess Christ as Lord. The majority of them will eventually accept Christ, and though they may not merit the Celestial Kingdom, they still will accept the gospel somed

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Paul Osborne
On Thu, 05 Dec 2002 08:11:16 -0900 "John W. Redelfs" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > After much pondering, Gary Smith favored us with: > >So, until you get your eating habit under control, you aren't > following > >the D&C, and this means you aren't a true Christian because you > aren't > >followin

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Elmer L. Fairbank
At 09:49 12/5/2002 -0900, BLT wondered : For years we referred to those outside the Church as "gentiles." Then that word wasn't good enough, so we stated saying "nonmember." Even that term is considered too politically incorrect. So what do we call them today? Lost Till the ever helpful

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Paul Osborne
I look at it this way: There are two kinds of Christians; those who have the fullness and those who don't. Celestial Christians = Latter-day Saints Terrestrial Christians = Baptists, Catholics, and the rest In this way we can believe our General Authorities when they refer to other churches as "

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Perhaps we need two different definitions: Christ-like, and Christian? "John W. Redelfs" wrote: > After much pondering, Mark Gregson favored us with: > >What do we know about being a true Christian? Not much, really, because > >God has never revealed any definition for "true Christian". He has

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread Marc A. Schindler
potential converts. :-) "Elmer L. Fairbank" wrote: > At 09:49 12/5/2002 -0900, BLT wondered : > > >For years we referred to those outside the Church as "gentiles." Then > >that word wasn't good enough, so we stated saying "nonmember." Even that > >term is considered too politically incorrect.

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-05 Thread John W. Redelfs
After much pondering, Paul Osborne favored us with: I look at it this way: There are two kinds of Christians; those who have the fullness and those who don't. Celestial Christians = Latter-day Saints Terrestrial Christians = Baptists, Catholics, and the rest In this way we can believe our Gener

RE: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-06 Thread Chet
Marc A. Schindler wrote: > Perhaps we need two different definitions: Christ-like, and Christian? Either you're being ironic (in which case, congratulations for such a clever pun!) or you're feeling just as frustrated as I. We should avoid labels, it is true, but we do need terms and definitio

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-06 Thread Marc A. Schindler
Chet wrote: > Marc A. Schindler wrote: > > Perhaps we need two different definitions: Christ-like, and Christian? > > Either you're being ironic (in which case, congratulations for such a > clever pun!) or you're feeling just as frustrated as I. We should avoid > labels, it is true, but we do n

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-10 Thread John W. Redelfs
Gary Smith favored us with: No, it isn't a straw man. It is exactly my point. Just where does a mortal being draw the line between what is a 'true' Christian and what isn't? Your definition keeps shifting on me. You said it was someone who fully followed Christ and his living prophets. Nope. Th

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-10 Thread John W. Redelfs
Gary Smith favored us with: My definition of a 'true' Christian, is one who seeks his/her best to follow Christ and good works (including those who have not yet learned of Jesus or the fulness of the gospel). This is a person who listens to the Light of Christ (or Holy Ghost for members) and seeks

Re: [ZION] True Christians

2002-12-12 Thread Stacy Smith
Except for the fact that there are probably many Latter-day Saints who are just as likely going terrestrial as well. Stacy. At 04:51 PM 12/05/2002 -0900, you wrote: After much pondering, Paul Osborne favored us with: I look at it this way: There are two kinds of Christians; those who have the