Hi Stefano, more comments inline ..
Stefano Bagnara schrieb: > Norman Maurer (JIRA) ha scritto: > >> [ >> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JAMES-787?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel >> ] >> >> Norman Maurer updated JAMES-787: >> -------------------------------- >> >> Attachment: localResolv-2.3.diff >> >> This is the diff for backporting to 2.3 branch . Any thoughts ? >> > > I'm not sure this is critical enough to justify a 2.3 backport. > > In the old "next-major" roadmap we even excluded the bug from the > next-major roadmap as a sign we could live with it. Also when planning > 2.3 release (30/Jun/06) we voted to exclude JAMES-302 from the release. > I know that we exclude it from next-major, but this was only the case ( for me ) because I wasn't aware how critical this bug is. > On trunk the fix for this issue is much better (and clean) and I like > it. I appreciate the choice to use the useLocalResolv configuration > parameter to enable the fix (this ensure backward compatibility). > I know that in trunk its much better but i can't find any better solution in 2.3 branch. The biggest problem is that the methods are static.. > Considering this "weird behavior" is there since 2.2.0 and that it was a > known issue at release time I'm -0 on backporting this to v2.3 branch. > Like I said I'm +1 for backporting the fix even if the solution is not such good as in trunk. > Maybe Noel's next-minor could be a better candidate for a full > dnsservice backport. > > Stefano > I agree that for next-minor a full backport whould be the best, but I think this will take long time . bye Norman --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
