Ignoring the condescending tone in many place, there are many great 
points are made here in identifying gotchas and offerring approaches. 
But characterizing the "bad" aspects as "EAI 2.0" and the alternative 
approaches as "SOA" is off-base.

The concepts of decoupling, location transparency, etc. are not unique 
to SOA. Looking up the address of another component isn't a 
breakthrough, nor even SOA-inspired. The specific approach of using 
service proxies isn't an "SOA requirement." It's simply one 
implementation possibility. The implication that if you're not doing it 
this way you're not doing SOA is incorrect, IMO.

-Rob

Reply via email to