Hi,

I use conditional configuration triggers with environment variables for different scenarios and I've noticed strange behaviors using these conditional blocs. Sometimes it works and some other times it doesn't and I can't pinpoint a reason for that.

For instance, I have an old WindowsXP VM that I boot once in a while to test old stuff. Sometimes I need to let this VM go to the outside world so I added this kind of conditional config to Shorewall :

file "rules":
?IF WinXP
  ?INFO Allow internet to WinXP
  ACCEPT { source=... ... ... }
?ENDIF

file "snat":
?IF WinXP
  ?INFO SNAT WinXP VM
  SNAT(...) { ... ... }
?ENDIF

NOTE: The rules themselves are irrelevant because it's not where the problem lies.

As usual, I always CHECK the config before using it:

# WinXP=1 shorewall ck
Checking using Shorewall 5.2.3.2...
Resetting....
   INFO: Allow internet to WinXP
   INFO: SNAT WinXP VM
Shorewall configuration verified

and if all goes well, reload:

# WinXP=1 shorewall reload
Reloading Shorewall....
done.

See the problem here? Where are the "INFO:" lines in the "reload" command? They should be there.

Verifying with "shorewall show | less" confirms that the related rules are not present.

Yet... sometimes... without even touching the configuration, using the "WinXP=1 shorewall reload" makes the "INFO:" lines visible and the rules are applied correctly.

What's wrong? (either on my part or Shorewall's :-))

PS: In case it helps, AUTOMAKE="Recursive" in "shorewall.conf"

Thanks.

--
ObNox


_______________________________________________
Shorewall-users mailing list
Shorewall-users@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/shorewall-users

Reply via email to