> a) users won't usually rotate pictures if they are auto-rotated
> according to the camera orientation.
 
Yes, I agree that in the case that the camera captures the autorotate setting, 
it's not used at all or hardly at all.
I purchased an underwater camera only a year ago that doesn't do this.... so 
believe it or not, not all cameras do autorotation / setting the exif rotate 
flag.  



> Cut the developers some slack :). If it proves to be the worst usability
> decision in human history, I am sure we'll get another icon sooner or
> later. Until then, there are bigger fish to fry.

Slack cut... :-)  and yes I agree that it's not the biggest issue.  But it 
would 
still be nice to have that icon as I find it would help me.  I don't see this 
as 
a large implementation effort.  Would you consider a patch?  I would need to 
get 
my hands dirty with Vala for the first time and find time for it, but it may be 
fun.  :-)


> From Peter DO Smith...
> Either way, can I suggest we strive for some civility in these discussions?
> We are all on the same side and have no need to prove a point.

I didn't mean to come off too harsh.  (see 3 fail references)  Sorry about 
that.  However, it seems like certain opinions are not given much consideration 
prior to being completely shut down.  


Also, some of these discussions/decisions could be made simpler if UI 
guidelines 
existed that focused on minimizing mouse clicks for example.

Lu Timdale
[email protected]



----- Original Message ----
From: Sebastian Spaeth <[email protected]>
To: [email protected]
Sent: Wed, September 1, 2010 3:30:53 AM
Subject: Re: [Shotwell] Photo-viewer and importing photos.

On 2010-08-31, Lu Timdale wrote:
> proposing is that 
> a) users don't usually rotate pictures ....   fail
> b) when they do, they only usually rotate one way.... fail
> c) when they want to rotate the other way, they have to know to hover over 
> and 

> then very intuitively hold the control key while clicking the rotate 
> button... 

> fail x3

Oh come on, the point about screen estate is a very valid one. And yes:
a) users won't usually rotate pictures if they are auto-rotated
according to the camera orientation.

b) Given that pictures are auto-rotated according to orientation when
taking, I know that my mother has no problems pressing that button 3
times. If she used that functionality more often, she would discover the
ctrl-click when hovering and reading the tooltip.

c) If it's described in the tooltip, it is actually discoverable.

Cut the developers some slack :). If it proves to be the worst usability
decision in human history, I am sure we'll get another icon sooner or
later. Until then, there are bigger fish to fry.

Sebastian
_______________________________________________
Shotwell mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.yorba.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/shotwell



_______________________________________________
Shotwell mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.yorba.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/shotwell

Reply via email to