PKIX is discussing the effect of a missing CRL at the moment.

It appears some people doing relying party tests in 5280 over-interpret the 
non-availability of a CRL as a hard-fail, and treat the CA products as invalid, 
in a belief that 5280 requires this of them. 

But, this is not actually required. And in like sense, it would not be required 
of a manifest.

There are of course certain questions regarding signed products which become 
unanswerable in the face of not having a manifest, or a CRL, but they are not 
hard-fails which would invalidate the entire object set, and by extension, the 
sub-tree of child products ad infinitum.

section 6. Local Cache Maintenance of the ARCH document does place an onus on a 
cache administrator to review the CRL/Manifest products and detect corruption, 
but its not presented as a strong/normative validation issue.

Can I ask relying party tool writers to consider this in their tools? Warnings 
are useful, but over-aggressive pruning or de-validation would not be good.

cheers

-George

_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to