I tried to post this yesterday in answer to a number of posts specifically addressed at me. I don't know if it got lost or blocked, but since reading Mike's post about 'niceness' (which I found quite disappointing) I've edited it to remove references that may be seen as insulting. I'm trying to post it again.

On 05/06/2008, at 12:30 PM, da...@alchemysa.com.au wrote:

Nenah offers Masura Emoto as a high authority. By his own admission Emoto "undertook extensive research of water around the planet not so much as a scientific researcher (because he isn't one) but more from the perspective of an ORIGINAL THINKER". Folks, please think carefully about what that really means while you read more of his dubious qualifications and theories. His 'water crystal' photographs prove nothing other than he's a talented photographer. Everyone knows that all snow flakes are different, so its pretty obvious that ice crystals of pure clear water are going to be 'prettier' than crystals of dirty brown water, especially when carefully selected and interpreted via Emoto's perspective of 'original thinking'. No-one but Emoto and his followers believes that these photos prove water can be 'imprinted', let alone that we can decode the meaning of these (non existent) imprints. And this guy is held up as one of the guru's in the field!

#### + Masaru Emoto www.hado.net (imprinting of water shown in photographs)

By the way, 'Dr' Emotos Alternative Medicine qualification comes from here... http://www.altmeduniversity.com/


#### (Nenah) David, people in the US are light years behind other countries...

Yep, some are certainly still stuck in the dark ages. Although amazingly the one's most hooked by these new superstitions often see themselves as the most enlightened.

#### (Nenah) Jacques Benveniste www.digibio.com (a conventionally trained scientist whose experiments taught him, much to his surprise, that water is indeed capable of being imprinted) + Masaru Emoto www.hado.net (imprinting of water shown in photographs) + anything by Glen Rein et al. (how our thoughts and coherent heart energy affect DNA, for starters -- Google Rein and Heart Math) + materials by others, lower half of page www.item-bioenergy.com/ infocenter/index.html + Lynne McTaggart: The Field (an excellent book summarizing the work of various physicists and scientists, including the late Benveniste) + James Oschman: Energy Medicine (another excellent book, highly respected, on the biology, anatomy and physiology of energy medicine) + Thompkins and Bird: The Secret Life of Plants (a classic book, well-written and still far ahead of its time, on various scientists in the field of energetics) + Nenah Sylver: Healing with Electromedicine and Sound Therapies, parts 1 and 2 (Townsend Letter, February-March and April-May 2008)

(Nenah)  The sources cited above speak for themselves.

They sure do and i hope the the readers will examine them FOR THEMSELVES.

####(Nenah) I thought this group was for learning. If someone has a different opinion from you, can you accept that without trying to make others inferior to you? Also, if you need to condemn or mock other people, what does that say about you?

It appears that the only learning you want to allow is the learning that agrees with you. Can't I 'learn people' something different? And I'm not trying to mock you. I'm just pointing out what I think of the idea of 'water memory', and the sources you quote.

#### (Shep) As if David or anyone has any idea what reality is. Please explain gravity if you're the master of reality,or why a refrigerator magnet can cling endlessly without any power source.

Shep, I don't have to 'explain' or understand gravity or magnetism in order to know they exist. It's 'bleedin obvious' they exist and if I didn't accept it I would soon be dead. Nenah however is asking you to believe, and presumably change your lifestyle to accommodate, something that can neither be observed or measured by humans or instruments.

#### (Shep) While your at it please explain time for us? Has any of us ever seen an atom? If I used the same logic for CS I'd be a smurf...by now, well supposedly...

I don't really understand your train of thought there, but theres no comparison between 'water memory' and CS because there is a ton of credible, measurable, repeatable research that proves silver kills germs. Theres no 'act of faith' required other than hoping it can do in a human body what it can demonstrably do in a petri dish. Here's over 100 papers that prove that silver kills germs... http:// robholladay99.tripod.com/cs1.htm

#### (Shep) David wasn't being disrespectful, as much as, just being closed minded. When you look out of the box, you see a lonely simplicity.

You're kinda right about that Shep. I will not 'open' my mind to superstitions.

#### (Marshall) Of interest is the change in the spectrum for water exposed to "Reiki", and water "prayed" over by my son and wife.

Marshall. Many of yours posts are enjoyable, informative and credible. But if you believe that water can be changed by praying over it then I doubt we will ever agree on this. I think you are always going to see in your experiments what you want to see. I agree of course that water can be momentarily (very briefly) be affected by magnetism or static electricity, but thats totally different from suggesting water can be permanently structured or imprinted.


regards
David










--
The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver.

Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org

To post, address your message to: silver-list@eskimo.com

Address Off-Topic messages to: silver-off-topic-l...@eskimo.com

The Silver List and Off Topic List archives are currently down...

List maintainer: Mike Devour <mdev...@eskimo.com>